If one thing fails, then try, try and try again. Having so far failed to win control over the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) (the entity that amongst other things appoints the heads of Peru’s electoral bodies), the far-right parties in Congress are now seeking legislation that would enable them to dismiss JNJ members by means of ‘constitutional accusations’. The Constitution Commission in Congress has approved a bill that would reform Article 99 of the constitution and enable members of Congress to remove the heads of the Jurado Nacional de Elecciones (JNE), the Oficina Nacional de Procesos Electorales (ONPE) and the Registro Nacional de Identificación y Estado Civil (Reniec).

The move threatens to compromise the independence of Peru’s electoral authorities by making these dependent on the goodwill of those elected to Congress. It follows attempts that have so far failed to ensure congressional control over the JNJ with the reinstatement of the two members it had sought to dismiss, Inés Tello and Aldo Vásquez. Further attempts seem likely. On 11 April, Congress approved an appeal to the Constitutional Tribunal (mostly appointed by the current Congress) to reverse their reinstatement.

The Fuerza Popular (FP) party led by Keiko Fujimori has persistently sought to challenge the electoral authorities, having narrowly failed to win the presidency in the 2021 elections. FP and its allies in Renovación Popular, Avanza Pais and Acción Popular appear determined to make sure that the next elections, scheduled for 2026, do not produce a victory for the left. Indeed, as we have seen last month, they have already secured constitutional changes that will work to their advantage in holding on to power beyond 2026. The FP stalwart, Martha Moyano, chairs the Constitution Commission.

In open opposition to this latest move, the JNE has issued a sharply worded statement that declares it “contrary to the principles that underpin the constitutional democratic rule of law, in particular the separation of powers, independence and impartiality” that “enable an eminently political organism such as the Congress of the Republic to have the competence to exercise control over the decisions that emit electoral organisms such as the Jurado Nacional de Elecciones”.

The JNE goes on to point out that the move would violate the American Convention on Human Rights and the jurisdiction of the Inter-American Court on Human Rights.