The attempts by the former chief public prosecutor, Patricia Benavides, to overturn the decision to suspend her by the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) received a further set back on 4 January when Judge Jorge Luis Ramírez declared inadmissible the writ (medida cautelar) presented by Benavides. Benavides, accused of being involved in a criminal network, is at the centre of congressional attempts to remove the members of the JNJ. However, this battle has yet to run its course.
Right-wing parties in Congress remain determined to remove the seven members of the JNJ. The JNJ is not only responsible for appointing and dismissing judges and public prosecutors but also for appointing and dismissing the heads of the three electoral bodies: the Jurado Nacional de Elecciones (JNE), the Oficina Nacional de Procesos Electorales (ONPE) and the Registro Nacional de Identificación y Estado Civil (Reniec).
Plans to dismiss the JNJ failed to achieve their objective last month. Now plans are being hatched for a ‘Plan B’ using the Congressional Sub-commission for Constitutional Accusations. A report is being prepared by the SAC on the basis of written responses from the JNJ members. This is expected to be discussed and voted upon on 16 January. If approved, the report would pass to the Permanent Commission of the Congress, and subsequently to the full Congress.
Although the penalties against the JNJ members are less drastic, they would require only 71 votes to be approved, not the two-thirds majority (87 votes) required previously. Although the three far-right parties (Fuerza Popular, Renovación Popular and Avanza País) remain supportive, there are growing doubts as to the position of more centre-right parties such as César Acuña’s Alianza para el Progreso.
Acuña has questioned a bill presented by Roberto Chiabra which would remove functions from the JNJ by putting Congress in charge of appointing and dismissing judges and senior prosecutors, claiming the importance of “defending institutionality, democracy and the stability of the country”.
The scale of the criminal operations allegedly undertaken by Benavides and her close associates is the subject of a useful piece in Ojo Público. This relates to the activities of Jaime Villanueva – a key confidant of Benavides who has since undertaken to provide evidence under a plea-bargain arrangement – in negotiating with members of Congress over the election of Josué Gutiérrez to the post of Ombudsman, the barring of the former chief public prosecutor Zoraida Avalos from future office, and the removal of members of the JNJ. Those with whom Villanueva negotiated included members with investigations hanging over their heads for corruption.
In his evidence, Villanueva also told of how Benavides worked with the former APRA minister, Hernán Garrido Lecca and officials in the Ministerio Publico to suspend the two investigators on the Lava Jato case, Rafael Vela and José Domingo Pérez. Garrido Lecca, along with other prominent Apristas, was under investigation for receiving US$200,000 from Odebrecht to help fund the party’s campaign in the 2006 elections.
The Ministerio Público under Benavides also stands accused of operating a scheme to harass probing journalists.
According to the annual report of the Oficina de Derechos Humanos of the Asociación Nacional de Periodistas, Peruvian journalists suffered 352 attacks in 2023, more than in any year so far this century.
Recent Comments