On 16 November Congress approved – by a margin of 93 to 28 with one abstention – a motion to change the constitution and to restore the Senate as a second chamber. To achieve this aim, a second vote will be needed. As was the case with the first vote, the second will need the support of at least 87 members, or two-thirds of Congress.
At the same time, members voted in favour of a text that introduced the unrestricted re-election of incumbent legislators: “senators and deputies may be re-elected immediately for the same position”. The move was approved with scant parliamentary debate and zero public consultation.
The vote goes against the result of a referendum held in 2018 in which voters opted overwhelmingly not to create a second chamber. The fear at that time was that it would simply produce more legislators of the same ilk as the single chamber. The members of the first chamber have proved themselves massively unpopular with the voting public.
Opinion polls consistently show that the climate of opinion has not changed since then. Less than 10% of those consulted think that the present Congress is doing a good job.
The vote also goes against the demand which surfaced in December 2022, with the removal of Pedro Castillo, that the whole constitution needs to be rewritten by a constituent assembly. Here sectors of the right in Congress are for rewriting only those aspects that favour their interests.
For many analysts the main motive for restoring the 60-member Senate and permitting immediate re-election would be to extend the political careers of the present members of Congress, or at least many of them. Legislation is also currently before Congress which, if approved, would enable incumbent governors and mayors at the sub-national level to be re-elected.
While the justification for such changes may be not to waste the experience gained by sitting legislators, governors or mayors, a more cynical interpretation is that it enables them to enjoy the benefits (legal or otherwise) of public office for longer or even in perpetuity. It also helps to detract from demands for a wholesale revision of the 1993 constitution which provided the basis for the pro-business policies associated with the Fujimori regime.
The restoration of the Senate has been advocated for some time by far-right groupings in Congress, notably Fuerza Popular. First mooted in 2022, the move was reformulated in order to win sufficient support. Opposition this time came mainly from the left and centre-left goupings such as Perú Libre, Cambio Democrático-JP, Bloque Magisterial and some independents.
Up until the self-coup (autogolpe) of President Alberto Fujimori Peru had had a bicameral system. However, the 1993 constitution did away with the Senate, perhaps in the belief (subsequently shown to be correct) that a single chamber – scaled down in the number of seats – would be easier for the executive to manipulate.
Now, however, the boot is on the other foot, and it is the legislature that has the executive where it wants it. The Boluarte administration is precariously dependent on the majority will in Congress, and the legislature has demonstrated its power to dismiss presidents at will. This has led to what the anthropologist Eduardo Ballón, in an interesting recent interview, called “parliamentary authoritarianism”.
Assuming that Congress will vote again to amend the constitution – possibly early in 2024 – it will remain an open question as to the basis on which a second chamber would be elected and what specific constitutional powers it would enjoy.
Recent Comments