Notwithstanding strong pressures from within the country and from abroad – notably from the United Nations – there are so far no signs that the Congress has any intention of retreating from its attempts to force out the seven members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) and replace them by appointments more inclined to heed the will of the Congress. The manoeuvre, which follows the designation of ‘dependable’ people as members of the Constitutional Tribunal and the Ombudsman’s Office (Defensoría del Pueblo), has raised concerns for the future independence of the judiciary as well as (potentially) that of the three electoral organisations whose appointments depend on the JNJ.
The move to submit the seven members of the JNJ to summary investigation in Congress for allegedly “grave” misdemeanours has reinforced concerns worldwide that Peru is fast moving in a non-democratic direction under the government of President Dina Boluarte. Human rights lawyers, including Samuel Abad (a former Ombudsman), have also slated the procedural deficiencies of the cases against the JNJ members. “The sacking of the JNJ members by means of a summary investigation that fails to respect due process and without there being a serious offence is a threat to its independence and autonomy” he is quoted as saying, “It affects the whole system of justice”.
For her part, President Dina Boluarte has shrugged off concerns that Peru is behaving in an increasingly undemocratic way. During a visit to New York, where she attended the UN General Assembly, Boluarte claimed that no-one should be free of investigations into their conduct. During her visit, Boluarte was greeted by vociferous demonstrations by Peruvians living in the United States. It seems that the visit did little to improve Peru’s poor image abroad.
Increasingly members of Congress in Peru have reacted against the Inter-American system of justice of which Peru is a member. The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) has many cases outstanding where complaints have been registered with regard to deficiencies in the Peruvian justice system. Both members of the left-wing Perú Libre party as well as parties of the extreme right have registered their anger at the role played by the IACHR. There have been several resolutions presented to Congress seeking to disassociate Peru from the American Convention on Human Rights.
On 21 September, Congress voted by 85 to ten, with nine abstentions, to allow extra time to conduct the summary investigation into the seven JNJ members.
Recent Comments