Twenty years ago, on 28 August, 2003, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) published its groundbreaking report into the nature and effects of two decades of political violence. It was groundbreaking in two key ways. First it provided the first detailed narrative history of the political violence that shook Peru in 1980 when Sendero Luminoso unleashed its bloody offensive in the small town of Chuschi in Ayacucho region. It remains the history of the period. Second it set out key recommendations as to how the country should process this legacy of violence and thus emerge strengthened from the experience.

The period that followed the downfall of the Fujimori government in 2000, first under the interim presidency of Valentín Paniagua (2000-01) and subsequently during the first years of the government of Alejandro Toledo (2001-06) had been times of high hopes that Peru would manage to achieve political reconciliation and move towards being a genuinely more inclusive and egalitarian country.

The Peru Support Group was there at the time and shared in this moment of optimism. To help back up the Commission and publicise the report’s findings, John Battle, then a Labour MP for Leeds, and Lord John Alderdice, visited the country in 2004, writing their own report on their return to the UK. Battle had been the foreign office minister with responsibility for Latin America. Alderdice had earlier been a Member and Speaker of the Northern Ireland Legislative Assembly. He had played a key role in brokering the 1998 Good Friday Agreement which helped to promote peace and reconciliation in Northern Ireland.

Twenty years later in May, Lord Alderdice, currently the president of the PSG, returned to Peru, accompanied by Ana Reyes Hurt, the PSG’s coordinator, to assess how far Peru has gone in implementing the TRC’s recommendations. They spent a week there interviewing leading actors in the political process of today’s Peru. Among those they interviewed were the prime minister, Alberto Otárola, the justice and human rights minister, Daniel Maurate, and the Attorney General, Patricia Benavides.

On the strength of their visit, they wrote a new report published this weekend by the PSG. It can be found here.

The report shows that despite many positive changes since 2003, crucial areas like security sector reform and addressing the underlying causes of violence – such as discrimination, poverty and marginalisation – remain much as before. It summarises the key recommendations made by the TRC in 2003, including the provision of justice to those affected, reparations, and the search for the disappeared. Among the report’s conclusions is that many of these concerns have been sidelined over the years. It picks up on the institutional resistances within the state to implementation of the TRC agenda.

It sets out three overriding recommendations:

  • The importance of security officials from Peru sharing the experiences with their equivalents in other countries that have more fully addressed post-conflict challenges so that they learn more of the processes and benefits of security sector reform.
  • The importance of government and other actors (including the business community) engaging more fully in the economic development and political representation of communities that were affected by the violence. Unless this happens, the problem of conflict is likely to recur.
  • The importance of not forgetting about past traumas but remembering them and thus helping to resolve them. Trying to bury the past is always a serious mistake.

On this last point, Lord Alderdice emphasised the significance of places like the Lugar de la Memoria, where he held a press conference on the final day of his visit. The LUM, as it is known, had been briefly and abruptly shut down by the right-wing mayor of Miraflores just prior to the visit. The press conference was one of the first acts that followed its re-opening.

Also, on the point of memory, Lord Alderdice picked up on the project at the Ombudsman’s Office (Defensoría del Pueblo) to digitalise the documentation amassed by the TRC. This, he said, needs to be given the resources and encouragement to complete it as quickly as possible.