The 8 and 9 August meetings, convened at the initiative of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and held in the Amazonian city of Belem, was organised in two parts. The first, with representatives from eight of the nine Amazonian countries, failed to achieve a consensus on Lula’s call for an agreement to reach zero deforestation by 2030. The second, with additional representatives from Indonesia, the Democratic Republic of Congo, and the Republic of Congo, called for financial assistance from the developed countries to ensure the conservation of the world’s tropical rainforests.

As previously reported, in the lead up to the summit, Amazonian indigenous organisations and their civil society allies had issued a declaration calling on the Amazonian governments to adopt urgent decisions to prevent the Amazon from reaching an environmental tipping point by committing to the protection of 80% of the Amazon basin by 2025.

Perhaps indicating their lack of commitment to the conservation of the Amazon rainforest, the presidents of only four of the eight Amazonian countries invited attended, among them Peru’s Dina Boluarte. French Guiana was not invited.

The resulting Belem Declaration expressed strong support for indigenous rights and protections, while also agreeing to cooperate on water management and health; to forge common negotiating positions at climate summits; to pursue policies of sustainable development; and to establish a scientific body to meet annually and to produce authoritative reports related to the Amazon rainforest.

However, the assembled representatives failed to agree on a common goal for ending deforestation but rather established an alliance for combatting forest destruction, with countries left to pursue their own individual deforestation goals.

They also refused to support Colombian President Gustavo Petro’s call for an end to new oil development in the Amazon. While they agreed to better combatting of cross-border environmental crime, they did not fix a deadline for ending illegal gold mining.

In response to the Belem Declaration, the civil society representatives assembled in Belem issued a Declaration of the Peoples of the Earth for the Amazon in which they congratulated the eight governments for resuscitating the relatively dormant Amazonian Cooperation Treaty Organisation (OTCA) and agreeing to incorporate civil society demands in OTCA’s future agenda.

However, they pointed out that the presidents’ declaration, while emphasising the importance of women and indigenous peoples, failed to recognise the important roles played by peoples of African descent, peasant communities and others.

They regretted the failure of governments to agree on a common goal for combatting deforestation, leaving each country to define its own commitment, and for not defining timelines in confronting the climate crisis.

As regards petroleum and mining, the countries only agreed to initiate a dialogue over the sustainability of extractive activities. Finally, they ignored the salience of land conflicts, the criminalisation and murder of environmental and human rights defenders, and the need for agrarian reform.

Such disappointing results reflect a long tradition of South American countries considering the Amazon basin as a neglected “backyard” while focusing their attention (and that of most of their populations) on the Atlantic and Pacific seaboards. Rather than a common patrimony to be cherished, the Amazon rainforest has often been seen as a barrier to integration and the source of resources to be exploited for the benefit of other regions.

The 9 August meeting, which included the twelve counties that account for 52% of the world’s primary tropical rainforests, concluded with a joint statement, “United for our Forests”, in which they announced the formation of a pact to demand that developed countries pay to help poorer nations combat climate change and preserve biodiversity.

They reaffirmed their commitment to reduce deforestation and find ways to reconcile economic prosperity with environmental protection. They expressed their concern for the failure of the developed countries to meet their climate change mitigation objectives and to respect their promise to create a fund of US$100 billion to combat climate change. They demanded that this commitment be increased to US$200 billion by 2030.

These meetings reflect Lula’s campaign promise to combat deforestation in the Amazon. In Brazil, which comprises about 60% of the Amazon basin, this has fallen by 42.5% in the first six months of Lula’s government. The summits also reflect his desire to project Brazil’s international leadership as a champion of the environment and a combatant against climate change, in sharp contrast to his predecessor, Jair Bolsonaro.

While the presence of Peru’s Boluarte was significant – the presidents of Ecuador and Venezuela were absent – the commitments she made will prove hard to implement and, indeed, the resolve of her administration to do so remains in doubt. Powerful interests are aligned in domestic Peruvian politics to accelerate the ‘development’ of the Amazon in ways that are far from sustainable, threaten faster deforestation, and pose a direct threat to indigenous livelihoods.

Boluarte’s presence in Brazil has caused a row in Peru for violating the constitutional precept against foreign travel when there is no vice-president to conduct official government business in her (or his) absence. A law passed to enable her to travel clearly violated constitutional norms, since laws cannot change constitutional norms.