On 4 July, the Supreme Court met to discuss the case levelled against the former chief public prosecutor, Zoraida Avalos. It ruled that it could not offer an opinion since it might prejudge further legal judgements.

As we reported two weeks ago, a group of Supreme Court judges had requested a meeting of the plenary of the Court to consider the attempts by Congress and the current chief public prosecutor, Patricia Benavides, to bar Avalos from future office for five years on the basis of a constitutional accusation against her.

The group of eight judges considered that the action against Avalos affected the independence of the judiciary.

The case against Avalos is that she failed to act with sufficient speed and vigour on denunciations against former president Pedro Castillo on account of corruption. Congress had voted 71 to 15 (with eight abstentions) to bar Avalos, a move that Benavides then sought immediately to open an investigation.

For her part, Avalos argued that she had not sought to delay the case against Castillo and that she had broken new ground judicially by opening an investigation into a sitting president.

It was ostensibly on the grounds that the Court might end up hearing the appeal from Avalos that it refrained from making a judgement on the matter. However, by not doing so, it failed to conspicuously respond to the broader issue of whether Congress is attempting to challenge the autonomy of the judiciary.