The long-running debate in Congress over draft Law 3518, which was rejected by the Indigenous Peoples Commission on 19 June, has now been abandoned by the Decentralisation Commission. It voted by a majority on 23 June that the legislation was not within its remit. As of now, the bill is therefore dead in the water. With both commissions thus refusing to vote on the bill and with the Indigenous Commission previously voting against it, the legislation has been removed from the congressional agenda.

If it had been approved by the full Congress, the bill would have transfered responsibility from the Ministry of Culture to regional governments for reviewing existing reserves in the rainforest set aside for indigenous people in voluntary isolation or initial contact and creating new ones.

Its proponents included business interests in the Amazon who wanted to gain access to the reserves for logging, mining, and coca cultivation, activities that they have characterised as “sustainable development”. These interests hold sway in the regional governments.

Opponents, which have included Amazonian indigenous organisations and national and international human rights organisations, feared that the removal of protection for vulnerable indigenous in isolation would endanger the rights and lives of some 7,500 indigenous people living in the rainforest and with little or no contact with the outside world.

Their cause had been taken up recently by Hollywood actor Mark Ruffalo (who played the character ‘Hulk’ in a succession of movies) who argued that “the indigenous peoples that guard the Amazon, the heart of our planet, are our true, real-life superheroes”.

Alberto Chirif a Peruvian anthropologist who was a co-author of the legislation recognising native communities back in the 1970s, likened the legislation to putting a fox in charge of the henhouse.

On 15 June, Avaaz, a community petitions platform, launched a global petition in defence of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation in 16 languages and in 200 countries. By 20 June, it had received over 550,00 signatures. It expects to obtain at least 750,000.

On 22 June just before the vote in Congress, the United Nations system in Peru emitted a pronouncement calling on the authorities to protect indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation because weakening such protection could generate “serious environmental and economic damage”.

The UN pronouncement reminded the Boluarte government that it has international and constitutional commitments to protect isolated peoples and invited it to respect them. It also argued that isolated peoples and their collectively managed forests are “indispensable for finding a solution to the climate crisis that the world is confronting”.

It claimed that “the indigenous territories of the Peruvian Amazon have demonstrated greater reduction in the rate of deforestation than other protected areas and a rate much greater than other forms of territorial management”.