The well-known environmental defender and forestry specialist Lucila Pautrat, recognised by the Ministry of Justice and Human Rights as such and whose record of denouncing illegal activities in the Peruvian rainforest goes back over twenty years, has been convicted by an appeals court of defaming Tamshi SAC, a highly controversial cacao company. The same company sued a Mongabay reporter in 2021 in what appears to be a pattern of legal intimidation (known in the UK as a SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation)).

The company accused Pautrat of having spread lies concerning its committing of environmental crimes and for lacking authorisation to operate the Tamshiyacu plantation in the Loreto region. Pautrat was condemned by a lower court in March 2021, and this was upheld by the higher court.

The national Ombudsman (Defensor del Pueblo) has declared that this decision generates a “negative precedent” in the efforts to protect environmental defenders, because it conveys the message that denunciations, demands and revindications will be silenced by the courts. He has promised to continue supporting Pautrat in her efforts to have the ruling annulled.