Last week we reported on a ruling by the San Martín supreme court ruling in favour of local indigenous communities over a long-standing dispute between the communities and the park authorities (the state and a national NGO) in regard to participation in park management and benefits. This week we report on a contrasting experience in the Madre de Dios region where a conservation area co-managed by the state and indigenous communities is celebrating its 21st anniversary.

On 28 April the UN Committee for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD) wrote to the Government of Peru requesting information about the remedying of violation of indigenous rights by the Cordillera Azul National Park and its REDD+ project. REDD+ is a programme for reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation in developing countries and forms part of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change.

The letter was in response to a formal petition presented by a consortium of local, regional, and national indigenous organisations to the CERD session in Geneva in August 2022. In the letter the Committee observes that the park was created in 2001 with the free, prior, and informed consent of the affected indigenous communities and details the restrictions imposed on the communities and the negative impacts on their livelihoods, food security and the transmission of traditional ecological knowledge.

In contrast with this experience, the Amarakaeri Communal Reserve in the Madre de Dios region has recently celebrated 21 years of successful co-management between the state and local indigenous communities.

The Reserve was created on 9 May 2002 as a protected area to be co-managed by the state, represented by the national parks authority (SERNANP) and the ECA Amarakaeri, representing 8 Harakbut, one Yine and one Matsiguenka indigenous communities and employing an intercultural governance model.

The park has an extension of 402,336 hectares. It was created to conserve a centre of great biological diversity owing to it being a refuge for a large variety of flora and fauna species and the cultural values of the communities.

The park management has organized its work along four lines: environmental, economic, social, and cultural. It has developed a Master Plan for the Reserve and an Institutional Life Plan for the ECA. Using these tools, the park management has maintained the conservation level at 99% and is moving towards financial sustainability by receiving payment for ecosystemic services under a REDD+ agreement which also provides training to community members to develop tourism initiatives.

Nevertheless, despite these achievements, the park faces several challenges. One of these is the effective recognition of the right of the communities to their own territories. The park is also located over important gas reserves so that there is always the latent threat that some or all of the park may be granted in concession for gas exploration. There is also the ever-present threat of illegal mining and drug trafficking. Finally, former regional governments began illegal construction of a highway through the park. While this is currently stalled, this also represents a latent threat.