The hard-hitting report by the Inter-American Commission of Human Rights (IACHR) on violations perpetrated by the security forces in December and January was published on 3 May. Amongst its recommendations is for the Boluarte administration to ensure a speedy and thorough investigation to identify those responsible for the killing of more than 50 civilian victims. For her part, President Dina Boluarte rejected the accusation made by the IACHR that these killings constituted “extra-judicial killings” and a “massacre”.

The IACHR report’s conclusions follows similar publications from Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch. However, as an official organisation to which Peru is a signed-up member, the IACHR document carries more political weight. Peru is treaty-bound to adhere to the recommendations made by the IACHR. The IACHR has repeatedly clashed with Peru over its human rights record and there is a large backlog of unresolved cases.

The report, based on two visits to Peru by researchers since January and which takes into account government observations, accuses the Peruvian police and army of “excessive, indiscriminate and lethal use of force” in dealing with protests across the south of the country in December and January, following the ousting of Pedro Castillo as president on 7 December. It claims that the wounds suffered show clearly the deliberate use of lethal weapons aimed at the upper half of victims’ bodies.

The report is also critical of the role of Congress in creating a polarised situation well before Castillo’s removal from office and urges it to abandon efforts to increase its control over the judicial and electoral authorities. It also urges the public prosecution service to embark on a thorough investigation into those who were responsible for the killings and asks that it should be given the financial resources to complete the task. It demands an end to impunity. The IACHR also criticises what it calls “the stigmatization” in public debate of peasants and indigenous peoples and the use of derogatory language accusing them of being ‘terrorists’.

Boluarte has politely said that the government will consider the IACHR’s 36 recommendations. However, these have been slated by far-right members of Congress who believe that Peru should not be beholden to such external pressures. The Fujimorista Martha Moyano is quoted as saying “Who do they think they are? Just let them wait to have our response”. The report has also been criticised by the right-wing mayor of Lima, Rafael López Aliaga, although he confessed he had not read it.

The Coordinadora Nacional de Derechos Humanos, the umbrella organisation that groups 78 human rights groups, has condemned Boluarte’s refusal to face facts. It accuses her of acting akin to the Fujimori regime in the 1990s.

A document which came to light in the publication Hildebrandt en sus Trece quotes Boluarte saying that Peru’s armed forces had taken what she called “administrative measures” in accordance with the “gravity” of the situation they faced.

The tensions between the human rights community, both in Peru and abroad, and the Peruvian military are of longstanding, given the reluctance of the armed forces to take responsibility for their role in what constitute human rights violations.