In an historic ruling which may have implications for other indigenous communities whose traditional territories overlap with national protected areas, the San Martín High Court has ruled in favour of the Puerto Franco indigenous community in a dispute with the Cordillera Azul National Park.

As this newsletter has previously reported, there have been long-running conflicts between park authorities and indigenous communities whose traditional territories overlap with the park over the recognition of the communities’ right to be consulted and have their lands titled, to participate in park management, and to share in the benefits received from the sale of carbon compensation rights.

In 2020, the Puerto Franco Kichwa indigenous community and its representative federation CEPKA presented their demand to the court in Bellavista and hearings were held in March of this year. The court has ruled that the community’s lands be titled. These lands had been previously incorporated into the park and have seen logging concessions imposed.

The court also ordered that the community be consulted about the creation of the park and be informed in detail by park management about the conservation activities carried out on its territory, especially the REDD+ project which has sold carbon sequestration rights to such extractive companies as Total Energies, Shell and BHP. These resources are administered by CIMA, a Peruvian conservation NGO, which has been contracted by the national parks authority (SERNANP) to manage the park.

This is the first time that the territorial rights of indigenous communities affected by the creation of natural protected areas without prior consultation have been recognised. It is also the first time that the right of such communities to share in the benefits generated by conservation activities have been upheld.

If this ruling is confirmed on appeal, it will represent a paradigm change in the system of park management in Peru which has hitherto followed the “wilderness” model of conservation through the creation of areas which have excluded or ignored the existence and rights of indigenous peoples who have traditionally lived in these areas and managed their resources.