A detailed report by Human Rights Watch, the US-based human rights agency provides possibly the definitive version of the killings that took place in Peru, mostly in the south, in December 2022 and January 2023. Entitled ‘Deadly Decline: Security Force Abuses and Democratic Crisis in Peru’, it concludes that “the armed forces and national police made disproportionate and indiscriminate use of force against demonstrators and passers-by in clear violation of international law”.

It also claims that these deaths constitute extra-judicial and arbitrary killings for which the state is answerable. Commenting on the report, HRW’s César Muñoz defines extra-judicial killings as those involving state actors in operations where the killings are deliberate, have the intention to cause harm, and are carried out without judicial mandate.

The report is based on 140 interviews with family members of those killed, policemen, prosecutors and other authorities. It is also based on revision of more than 37 hours of video material and other relevant photographic evidence. It points to 49 deaths, of which 39 were shot by the security forces. It discards the notion that citizens bore lethal arms against the police. It also establishes that, of the 49, 15 were passers-by, three were observers and three were at the scene attempting to help those who were wounded. The report thus bears witness to a shoot-to-kill policy. In the case of Ayacucho, troops employed laser technology to improve their shooting accuracy.

HRW points to 125 persons receiving bullet wounds, although it says the figure could be much higher. The lack of precise information points to the failure of the authorities to follow up on these incidents. It claims that the kind of arms used in southern Peru against protestors was not replicated in Lima. HRW is highly critical of the work of the public prosecution service which failed to assemble evidence subsequent to these violent incidents. In Andahuaylas, it failed to organise autopsies prior to the burial of victims. In Cusco and Arequipa, prosecutors failed even to collect evidence of public video footage. The ministry of the interior comes under criticism for failing to investigate police responsibilities.

HRW recommends that a commission of international experts should be invited to visit Peru to undertake a serious investigation as to responsibilities. According to Muñoz outsiders would provide the necessary independence in a context of polarisation. HRW also calls for the armed forces to be removed from all tasks of crowd control and for practices of judicial impunity in the security forces to be ended. It calls on foreign governments to push for proper investigation into responsibilities up to the highest levels of authority, including the president, ministers and heads of the armed forces.

A group of deputies from the European Parliament has called upon the Boluarte administration to put an end to violence and to guarantee the right to protest in Peru. It urges the government to end practises of criminalising and stigmatising protestors.