It has been a week of contrasts in which the gulf between Lima and the provinces, especially in the south, has seldom seemed starker. While in Puno they buried the dead following the killing of 18 protesters on 9 January, in Lima Prime Minister Alberto Otárola, seeking a vote of confidence from the far-right dominated Congress, condoned police methods and vowed to continue ‘pacifying’ the country.
The week began with widespread demonstrations in Juliaca against the Boluarte government, calling for her to resign and for immediate elections both for president and Congress. These were met with fierce repression from police detachments flown in to Juliaca to quell the demonstrations. No less than 17 people were shot dead with live ammunition on Monday 9 January. A 15-year-old subsequently died in hospital from his wounds on 12 January. A policeman also lost his life when his car was torched by angry demonstrators. Many more people were wounded.
Dan Collyns in The Guardian, quotes Javier Torres, an expert on regional politics in Peru: “Our security forces are accustomed to shooting people but I think that here they have crossed a line that has not been crossed before (…) It was a massacre; I can’t find any other term to describe it.”
Peasant communities from across the Altiplano marched towards the region’s two main urban centres, Juliaca and the city of Puno further south, in anger. Quechua-speaking communities from the north marched on Juliaca, Aymara communities from the south on Puno. Their fury at the ouster of Pedro Castillo as president was palpable. People in Puno had voted massively – by over 85% – for him in preference to Keiko Fujimori in the second round of presidential elections in 2021. They took seriously his promises to offer a new deal for the rural poor. Puno, where indigeneity underscores social divides, is at once one of Peru’s more rural regions as well as one of its poorest.
However, protests were not confined to Puno. In Cusco, too, rural communities began to mobilise and to descend on Cuzco city to register their voices against the government. One of their number was shot dead on 11 January. Street battles took place, particularly in the vicinity of the city’s airport. Impromptu roadblocks were reported on many of the region’s main highways, once again blocking the free flow of passengers and goods.
Similar disturbances were reported elsewhere in the south of the country, in Arequipa, Ayacucho and Apurímac. There were also renewed demonstrations in some other parts of the country. In several places, property was deliberately vandalised by small groups, taking advantage of the disarray. The situation made it easy for old scores to be settled; in Espinar, Cusco, there was a violent attack on Glencore’s Antapaccay mine, long a source of local discord.
The Defensoría del Pueblo reported on 12 January that a total of 49 people had lost their lives since the beginning of December and that, according to Health Ministry figures, 668 people had been wounded, nearly half since 4 January.
In Lima, the government vowed to push ahead with its pacification strategy. Prime Minister Alberto Otárola expressed little remorse for those who had lost their lives in previous days. The government has repeatedly sought to pin the blame for disturbances on ‘vandals’ and ‘agitators’. It has also made much of media claims that Evo Morales, the former president of Bolivia, was behind the bouts of violence in Puno. President Dina Boluarte issued orders that Morales should be prevented from entering Peru – that is, should he choose to do so. She also ordered home the Peruvian ambassador to La Paz.
The hard line taken reflects in large part the need to appease the far-right parties that dominate the Congress, Fujimori’s Fuerza Popular, Renovación Popular, and Avanza País, the same parties which had relentlessly pursued the Castillo government since it was first elected. In line with the Constitution, the present cabinet (appointed in December) had to receive a vote of confidence in Congress. With support from these three parties plus others on the right, this was achieved in a session on 11 January: 73 members voted in favour, 43 against (mainly on the left) and six abstained.
In his speech to Congress, Otárola congratulated the national police force for its efforts to control social convulsion and pledged to restore order come what may. He repeated the government’s narrative about the role of political agitators. Responding to Otárola’s address, politicians from the far right claimed that the protests were animated by ‘terrorists’. In a press conference the day before, Otárola claimed that protests were being funded by drug traffickers and what he called “foreign influences”. He said that the demonstrations in Puno were a “hangover (resaca) from the coup d’état” that Castillo “had attempted to organise” at the beginning of December.
On 12 January it became clear that the government had used the Christmas ‘truce’ period to stock up with armaments to deal with continued demonstrations. The police force signed contracts on 20 and 27 December to acquire ammunition and tear gas cannisters from Brazilian and local suppliers, costing US$667,045.
The government has come in for strong criticism from the Defensoría for the methods used to thwart disturbances. On 10 January, the Defensoría issued a pronouncement demanding that the “competent institutions” investigate and punish those responsible for all the deaths produced in Juliaca.
Government officials, including Boluarte and Otárola as well as Interior Minister Víctor Rojas and Defence Minister Jorge Chávez, face a preliminary investigation by the Public Prosecutors Office “for presumed crimes of genocide, homicide and the severe injuries perpetrated during demonstrations in the months of December 2022 and January 2023 in the regions of Apurímac, La Libertad, Puno, Junín, Arequipa and Ayacucho”. The former prime minister, Pedro Angulo, and interior minister, César Cervantes, will also be included in the investigation.
For its part, the Asamblea Nacional de Gobiernos Regionales, which represents the governorships of Peru’s 25 regions, issued a statement urging the immediate bringing forward of elections “as the effective solution to the political crisis”, demanding a full investigation into the deaths in Puno and elsewhere. It also condemned acts of vandalism, urging protestors to be wary of provocations by “violent groups”.
Abroad, a wide range of human rights groups, including the Peru Support group and the Plataforma Europea Perú (PEP), have condemned the violence used by Peruvian police to contain protests. The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights dispatched a commission on 10 January to Peru to investigate allegations of human rights violation. Having visited Arequipa and Juliace on 12 January, it was due to present its preliminary conclusions on 13 January.
Eduardo García, the labour minister, was the latest minister to resign from the cabinet. He did so on 12 January exhorting the government to “express the grief we feel for the lives” of the deceased in Puno and Cusco and to “recognise that errors were committed that should be corrected and not repeated”.
Recent Comments