President Pedro Castillo swore in a new cabinet on 25 November following the rejection by the Standing Committee (Mesa Directiva) in Congress of a vote of confidence requested previously by the outgoing prime minister, Aníbal Torres. Torres has now been replaced by Betssy Chávez, formerly a minister of labour, who was forced to resign in May following a motion of censure over her handling of an air traffic controllers strike.

Much of the previous cabinet has been reappointed, though there are six new names. Kurt Burneo continues as finance minister and César Landa as foreign minister.

Earlier in the week, Torres had attached a motion of confidence to a bill seeking to repeal a law previously passed by Congress on the use of referendums. Speaking on behalf of the Standing Committee, José Williams, the president of Congress, announced its “complete rejection” of the vote of confidence. Williams, a retired army general, is a member for the far-right Avanza País party.

Peru’s 1993 constitution contains a ‘double death’ procedure whereby the president may dissolve Congress if it fails to approve two successive votes of confidence in a five-year presidential term and the Congress can force the resignation of the president either by impeachment or by a constitutional accusation in specific circumstances.

Notwithstanding last week’s visit by a delegation from the Organization of American States (OAS) which sought to promote dialogue between the government and Congress, relations have thus become even more fraught since its departure on 23 November.

In inviting the OAS to intervene, Castillo evidently hoped that this would provide him with a breathing space. This does not appear to have been the result.

The former president of Congress, María del Carmen Alva, described Chávez’s appointment as a “clear provocation” on the part of the president. The Chávez cabinet will need to receive a vote of confidence in Congress within a maximum of 30 days. If Congress refuses it, it could thus lead to the dissolution of Congress and fresh elections. This happened under President Martín Vizcarra in 2020.

While the possibility of dissolution comes one step nearer, Congress, for its part, may claim that the circumstances in which it denied a vote of confidence in Torres’ cabinet responded to unconstitutional procedures on the part of the executive. It has announced that it will submit such a claim to the Constitutional Tribunal. On 23 November the Sub-Commission for Constitutional Accusations (SAC) announced its intention to debate a fresh constitutional accusation against Castillo for attaching a vote of confidence to the bill repealing the law on referendums.

The latest skirmish represents a qualitative deterioration in an already poisonous relationship between the left-of-centre executive and the far-right majority in Congress, taking place hard on the heels of the OAS delegation’s departure from Lima. During its visit, the delegation – which included no less than five foreign ministers from other Latin American countries – had listened to the opinions of the heads of the executive, Congress and the judiciary, as well as to representatives from political parties, civil society organisations and varying areas of officialdom.

Castillo’s hope in inviting the OAS to intervene was that, at the very least, it would delay what he saw as an institutional coup in the making. How much the delegation will have contributed to resolving the impasse over President Pedro Castillo’s future, is hard to know. Their immediate task is to write a report and submit it to the Permanent Commission of the OAS. How long this will take and its form are also hard to know.

What is clear is that the conflict remains unresolved and, indeed, even more embittered than before. The OAS may exercise at least a restraining function. If the Congress persists on its various strategies to force Castillo from office in advance of the report’s publication, Peru’s standing in the hemisphere will certainly be affected.

But the more far-right members of the Congress appear not to be too worried about international niceties and determined to push ahead with moves to remove Castillo come what may.

One of the routes to force Castillo out is, as we reported last week, the claim that he committed an act of treason in telling a journalist of plans to give Bolivia an exit to the sea through Peruvian territory. On 22 November, the Constitutional Tribunal (TC) ruled in Castillo’s favour by rejecting a move by the SAC to approve the accusation against Castillo for treason being passed on to the plenary.

The TC decided unanimously (and perhaps not surprisingly) that there was no case to answer since Castillo had simply proffered a suggestion, not any action that could be construed as treasonable. As many commentators have pointed out, this was the accusation against Castillo most likely to fail.

Notwithstanding this, on 24 November, Williams responded to the TC’s ruling not by dropping the matter but by passing the accusation back to the SAC so that it could be reformulated. This appears to enjoy the support of Lady Camones, the president of the SAC, whose casting vote tilted the sub-commission into ordering the accusation to be taken up by the Standing Committee in Congress.

At the same time, Congress appears insistent on pursuing other constitutional denunciations against Castillo for alleged corruption and malpractice, despite Article 117 of the Constitution which prevents a sitting president from being accused in this way, except for very specific instances of wrongdoing that do not include corruption (but do include treason). Proceedings to impeach Castillo have yet to receive sufficient support in Congress.