Last week’s web symposium at Washington DC’s Wilson Center explained the role of mining in the ‘green economy’. The speakers were from three of the main international mining companies investing in Latin America: Anglo American (Cristina Bruce), Newmont (Briana Gunn) and BHP (René Muga), and one contributor, Jenna Schroeder, from the US State Department. In the chair was Benjamin Geda, acting director of the Center’s Latin American Program.

Geda pushed the speakers to spell out the costs and challenges of taking mining forward in ways conforming to modern Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) requirements on businesses.

The speakers insisted on the centrality and possibility of developing technology and practices which can make mining sustainable and they were adamant that whatever costly investment this meant in the short term, such investment had to happen for mining to go forward.

The speakers of course were representatives of three of the more progressive mining companies investing in mining in Latin America today. All were making the case that investment had to be made to make mining environmentally and socially acceptable, that this is possible but costly, and that their companies were prepared to take the investment on board. This, they asserted, would produce conflict between short-run and long-run needs, but was inevitable and necessary. One speaker was vocal on the importance of government monitoring of appropriate behaviour to ensure that any harm was properly regulated.

The heart of the issue was a combination of the clear threat of harm that mining poses and the reputational damage that the harm would bring.

Speakers agreed that technologies can be developed that will safeguard the social and environmental vulnerability of communities while still making mining economically viable. Partly, they claimed, the answer will lie in different lines of investment – away from thermal coal and oil and into copper and nickel.

The answer would also lie in different technologies for producing the same commodity – ‘greener’ mining. In northern Chile, for example, desalination is increasingly being used to provide the large amounts of water used in mining, particularly in treating lower ore grades. Similarly, it was pointed out that mining operations are moving from using diesel to green electricity and hydrogen.

For the companies and governments, the most difficult issue to crack, it was claimed, is obtaining the ‘social licences’ to mine. Both actors need to work on collecting and communicating the data to demonstrate the controversial point that mining can indeed be ‘green’ and socially acceptable in curtailing the threats it poses.

It would have been helpful if the symposium had contained more discussion and evidence to advance that conversation. It did not go far in clarifying what ‘green mining’ might really mean – or how much it would cost.