After winning the recent election in Madre de Dios, Luis Otsuka has called for mining law reform, claiming that current laws prevent the formalisation of artisanal and small scale mining (ASM) in Madre de Dios and elsewhere.

“Why do they penalise it, when it’s such an important activity which promotes development and economic growth in our country”, he said, “it has been demonised”. He went on “the NGOs have been trying to impede this important activity, which could take us out of poverty. He said that “despite these natural resources we live in extreme poverty … new development policies must be created to benefit all Peruvians.”

The governor elect’s statement highlights the ongoing challenges of ASM formalisation, where policies over many years to this end have left few miners able to fully legalise themselves, leaving many in an intermediary stage of formalisation, unable to progress further. Others operate in illegal areas and therefore are unlikely ever to be considered as legal.

The challenges are particularly acute in Madre de Dios, where there are large numbers of established migrant ASM communities, significant environmental protections, and conflicts with land and concession owners.

As we regularly report, there are complex competing demands on land and resources in Peru, particularly in areas such as Madre de Dios. Artisanal and small-scale miners can come into conflict with indigenous groups which can both seek to protect their land from mining, or which participate in mining themselves.

As we reported in the wake of the 2 October regional governorship elections, Otsuka faces investigation for a number of alleged crimes: promoting illegal mining, money laundering, human trafficking and environmental crimes. He is also accused of collusion, influence peddling, embezzlement and the misuse of public funds.