Webinar: Defending the Defenders

The PSG, in conjunction with Latin America Bureau (LAB), organised a well-attended webinar on 20 October, entitled ‘Environmental Defenders in Peru Today’. The panel included Katie Jones from LAB; Josep Iborra Plans, the Amazon coordinator for the Brazilian Comissão Pastoral da Terra; Barbara Fraser from Earthbeat and the National Catholic Reporter; Andrea Bernal from the Centro Amazónico de Antropología y Aplicación Práctica (CAAAP) and Teresita Antazu, from the Yanesha community in Peru and a leader of the Asociación Interétnica de Desarrollo de la Selva Peruana (Aidesep). The meeting was chaired by John Crabtree from the PSG.

John launched the webinar drawing attention to the relationship between deforestation and the struggles of indigenous groups in the build-up to the COP-27 meeting in Egypt next month. Katie Jones followed through with an analysis of the killings in the Amazon in recent years as cited in the recent Global Witness report. She made mention of LAB’s research and publications on land conflicts in Latin America more generally and in Peru specifically, and the way in which in Peru indigenous peoples faced a variety of threats from both land grabbers and different illegal activities.

In his presentation, Josep (or Zezinho as he prefers to be called), provided a panoptic coverage of conflict and violence in Brazil and the other countries of the Amazon basin. According to his figures the largest number of conflicts had taken place in Brazil, but of those involving indigenous peoples, Peru was not far behind Brazil. In Peru, the main causes of conflict were the inroads made by activities connected with mining and hydrocarbons. In terms of assassinations, the country worst affected was Colombia, although Peru had the worst record for the assassination of indigenous people. He emphasized that assassinations were not isolated events but closely connected with business activities and the quest for natural resources.

In her presentation, Barbara provided recently updated information on the extent of deforestation across the Amazon basin according to which 33% is intact, 42% degraded, 6% highly degraded and 20% transformed. Brazil and Bolivia may be reaching an irreversible tipping point. Although in Peru this is not yet the case, the deterioration in more recent years has been rapid. She then identified the drivers of deforestation in each country (and how they vary), what drives the drivers, and who suffers. She ended on some thoughts on how best to respond from outside Amazonia, including pushing for the implementation of protected areas, the enforcement of traceability of goods like gold and beef, and persuading countries to sign up to the Escazú Agreement.

Andrea focused her presentation on how in Peru, despite pretensions to the contrary, the system of state protection of environmental defenders simply is not working. Faced with this reality, indigenous communities were increasingly forced into finding ways of protecting themselves. The state tallies of threats and assassinations are deficient, and alternative registers, such as those of the National Coordinator of Human Rights, show a much more depressing reality. The justice ministry has only four people working on over 250 cases. Of these, the great majority concern problems of criminalisation. And the problem is magnified because the attacks on defenders are not against individuals but whole communities.

Finally, Teresita spoke of the work of Aidesep which has long been the main institution bringing together the indigenous peoples of the Peruvian Amazon. She spoke of the relationship of peoples to the forest, and how this is threatened by depredation from outside business interests seeking to make money out of the Amazon. These include illegal miners, timber companies, drug traffickers as well as farmers seeking to sow crops like rice and soya. She also emphasized the negative role of the state in building roads and damming rivers. She described various initiatives being adopted by Aidesep including a system of early warning alerts by which threats can be identified quickly. She finished by stressing the need for indigenous peoples to act and to instruct their children to defend their inheritance.

You can listen to the presentations and Q and A here.