The noose seems to be tightening around the neck of Peru’s embattled president, Pedro Castillo. On 11 October, the chief public prosecutor (Fiscal de la Nación) Patricia Benavides took an unprecedented step of constitutionally denouncing Castillo on charges of corruption and for leading a “criminal organization”. Benavides has passed these charges on to the congressional Subcomission of Constitutional Accusations, presided over by the (until recently removed) president of Congress, Lady Camones. It will be considered by the whole Congress on 3 November.
This move throws into focus the wording of Article 117 of the constitution. This states (our translation) that “The President of the Republic can only be accused, during his [or her] period of office, for treason against the fatherland; for impeding presidential, parliamentary, regional or municipal elections; for dissolving Congress except in cases envisaged by Article 134 of the Constitution; or for impeding the meeting or operation of either the National Electoral Jury or other organisms of the electoral system”. Investigations into wrongdoing can be carried out, but no formal accusation can be made until the presidential terms has ended. In this case it would be 28 July 2026.
In her denunciation, Benavides frames the charges against Castillo under the UN Convention against Corruption which, amongst other things, establishes that presidential immunity does not impose limits on investigation, trial and punishment. She argues that the convention, ratified by Peru, overrides the constitution. However, this reading is open to question as measures to avoid the impunity of officials needs to conform to juridical norms. These are established by the constitution in the view of various constitutional experts.
The way by which Congress can vote to get rid of a president is established under Article 113. This is through impeachment. Here the relevant concept is “permanent moral incapacity”, a notion which is hard to define and highly subjective in its interpretation. The Congress has already tried twice to impeach Castillo on these grounds but has failed to muster sufficient votes (two-thirds of its members) on both occasions.
Prime Minister Aníbal Torres argues that Benavides’ strategy to force out Castillo is in violation of Article 117. “It’s not a matter of applying the Convention but discussing a current national case in accordance with national legislation”, he is quoted as saying “I am going to ask the United Nations to issue an opinion on this”. It appears that the foreign ministry is doing this.
Congress may seek to use Article 114 to oust Castillo, suspending him from office on the basis of “temporary incapacity”. This has the advantage over impeachment of only requiring a simple majority in Congress. But this too raises the question of what is meant by ‘temporary incapacity’. This could be taken to mean physical incapacity, but the term has never been properly defined in law. Article 114 also allows that suspension when a president “finds himself [or herself] the subject of judicial proceedings in line with Article 117”.
The public prosecutor’s office has brought together various of the denunciations of corruption made against Castillo in recent weeks. It has also detained a number of officials who it believes to be involved, as well as raiding the offices and homes of parliamentarians. Benavides was emphatic in her accusations: “We have found grave indications of the presumed existence of a criminal organization embedded (enquistada) in the Government Palace whose aim is to collar, control and direct contractual processes with a view to obtaining illicit gains”. She went on to accuse this criminal organization of seeking to obstruct the course of justice.
For his part, Castillo vehemently denies the charges lodged against him, accusing Benavides of wanting to orchestrate a “coup d’état in Peru”. He has previously questioned Benavides’ motivation, invoking “dark forces” in play.
Vice-president Dina Boluarte also faces constitutional denunciations. Were she to be replaced, the next in line would be the president of Congress, José Williams Zapata. The former general is a member of the far-right Renovación Popular group, led by the newly elected mayor of Lima, Rafael López Aliaga.
Recent Comments