The election of a new Ombudsman (Defensor del Pueblo) suffered another setback this week as a Constitutional Court in Lima ruled that the Special Committee of the Peruvian Congress should suspend the process until an earlier injunction (issued in May) is fully complied with.
Back in May, the workers’ union at the Defensoría presented a protective action (writ of amparo) against the special congressional committee denouncing serious infringements of due diligence as defined by the legislation governing the Defensoría. This specifies that the committee in charge of evaluating candidates for Defensor should be comprised of nine parliamentary members in line with the relative weight of their respective parties. The Congress had decided to form a committee including spokesmen of each parliamentary group and including the former president of Congress, Maria del Carmen Alva, as a ‘supernumerary’ member. The committee had eleven members, not nine.
The Defensoría workers union also questioned the substance of the process of choosing a new Defensor, arguing that it had omitted statutory citizen’s participation and a citizen veto over the candidates. The timetable adopted also cut short the prescribed time for debate and publication of the candidates’ names. Alva defended her involvement claiming that a labour union lacked the legitimacy of Congress.
The injunction halted the process until June when Congress decided to move ahead, changing the members of the committee but without altering the numbers involved. Congress argued the injunction referred to the membership of the committee, not the overall process. The president of the new committee was Freddy Diaz from the Alianza Por el Progreso (APP).
The committee members then presented eight candidates for the new Defensor. On 5 August, it whittled these down to three whose names would be put before Congress for the final selection: Carlos Castro, Jorge Rioja, and Beatriz Ramírez.
A new scandal then hit the committee. A staffer from the office of Diaz accused him of raping her in the Congress building at the end of July. The case, which is still under investigation, prompted Diaz’s rapid exit from the committee. Notwithstanding, the committee still went ahead with the presentation of its top three candidates on 5 August. Three days later, the Constitutional Court of Lima once again halted the process, ruling that the original writ of amparo was still in force and that the injunction covered the entirety of the process, not just the membership of the committee.
The Defensoría del Pueblo plays a vital function in protecting human rights and abuses of privilege. Its independence is guaranteed under the constitution. In the past, it has played a key role in mitigating political crises and resolving clashes of authority between state powers. The inconsistencies and omissions in the selection of a new Defensor put its future at risk.
The case has also brought into conflict the judiciary and the legislature. According to the former, the claims made by the union must be taken fully into account. Separately, various members of Congress have criticised the suitability of the shortlisted candidates.
Recent Comments