More than 40 pro-indigenous and civil society organisations, along with the national Ombudsman (Defensor del Pueblo), the Ministry of Culture and others, have expressed shock and indignation at a 2 March ruling by the Constitutional Tribunal (TC) that free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) is not a fundamental right protected by the constitution. FPIC is enshrined in ILO Convention 169, signed and ratified and in force since 2 February 1995 and regulated by the Prior Consultation Law (29875) of 31 August 2011.
The case before the TC involved two peasant communities in Puno region, Chila Chambilla and Chila Pucará. The TC ruled that a mining concession on their territories could not be annulled simply on the grounds that the communities had not been consulted. The TC thereby denied that prior consent is a fundamental right and that ILO Convention 169 enjoys constitutional status. Unless corrected, the ruling will undermine indigenous rights enshrined under ILO 169, including their right to traditional territories, to prior consent, to free determination, and to intercultural health and education. On 4 March the Legal Defence Institute (IDL) and the Human Rights and Environment Association (DHUMA) presented a legal appeal, arguing that the ruling was invalid (“tiene un vicio de nulidad”).
The TC argued that the right to prior consultation does not appear either expressly or implicitly in the constitution. As a result, it cannot be described as a fundamental right and cannot be enforced via a writ of habeas corpus. This flies in the face of large amounts of jurisprudence involving many precedents that recognise and enforce the right to FPIC in Peru by the TC itself or more widely in Latin America by the Inter-American Court of Human rights (IACHR). The IDL’s lawyers and most of their colleagues sustain that the rights recognised in ILO 169 and other international human rights treaties signed and ratified by Peru are – and have been – recognised as fundamental human rights.
The Amazonian indigenous organisation AIDESEP described the Tribunal’s ruling as an act of “racism translated into law” and stated that the decision only made visible the prevalent racism that indigenous peoples face. The national indigenous women’s organization ONAMIAP declared that the ruling represented “the continuation of the politics of colonialism”. The indigenous rights NGO IDLADS fears that this could be the beginning of the denial of other rights contained in human rights treaties.
The Awajún and Wampis autonomous territorial governments expressed concern for the possible impact of the ruling on a case involving oil Block 116, currently before the TC. The courts suspended activities on Block 116 due to the failure to apply FPIC. However, the state has appealed the decision and the case is about to be heard by the very tribunal, the TC, that has just ruled not to recognise this right.
The Ministry of Culture characterized the TC’s ruling as a step backwards. It affirmed that prior consultation ought to be respected and guaranteed by the state and pledged to continue promoting and implementing FPIC. The Defensoría stated that the ruling “constitutes a serious reverse in the protection of the rights of indigenous peoples” and that it “contravenes the constitution, international treaties and abandons without justification the standards established by previous jurisprudence”. It went on to state that it would inform the IACHR of the ruling.
Recent Comments