Peru’s Constitutional Tribunal (TC) voted by four to two to uphold a law, previously passed by Congress, that seeks to restrict the use that can be made of executive prerogatives to dissolve Congress in certain circumstances.

As we mentioned last week, the TC had been called upon by the executive to oppose the law on the grounds that it violated the constitution. The law restricts the ability of the president to dissolve Congress on questions of confidence when these relate to matters of constitutional reform, or on issues that are the exclusive responsibility of the Congress.

The law would therefore prevent an instance such as the use made of dissolution by former president Martín Vizcarra when, in September 2019, he dissolved congress on a matter of confidence relating to the appointment of TC members, a congressional responsibility.

According to the constitution, the executive can close down Congress (subject to a fresh election) when Congress denies it a vote of confidence on more than one occasion in a five-year term.

To rule the law unconstitutional, the executive needed at least five votes. It won only two, from the more liberal minded TC members Eloy Espinosa-Saladaña and Mariela Ledesma. The four more conservative-minded members – Augusto Ferrero, Manuel Miranda, Ernesto Blume and José Luis Sardón – voted to uphold the congressional position.