The Constitutional Tribunal (TC) held a public audience on 26 January on the vexed issue of the presidential prerogative to dissolve Congress when the latter denies the executive branch a vote of confidence on two occasions during a five-year term. While the dispute relates back to the closure of Congress by former president Martín Vizcarra, the issue forms part of the strategy by Congress to whittle down the powers of the executive.

While the 1993 constitution enables a president to dissolve Congress, the Congress can also impeach a president on certain specified grounds when approved by no less than two-thirds of Congress.

In the public audience held by the TC, the proponents of the congressional position argued that the so-called ‘law of authentic interpretation’, passed by Congress, should be declared to be in line with the constitution. They argued that it was valid to challenge previous verdicts of the TC that upheld the executive’s position and that doing so would serve to avert instances of arbitrary government behaviour.

Previous TC verdicts, they argued, should not be frozen in time but should be reinterpreted according to changing circumstances.

Those defending the executive’s position argued that this was not the case, and that judicial precedent should be observed. They also stated that use of a ‘law of authentic interpretation’ could not be used to amend the constitution and that the move threatened to materially alter the balance of constitutional power between the executive and legislature.

Víctor García Toma, the lawyer acting for Congress, affirmed that “within the structure of the state the primary interpreter of the constitution is the Congress”. This line of reasoning appears to challenge the role allotted to the TC.

The TC now has to vote in secret on the matter before it. To sustain the executive position will require the votes of no less than five members of the tribunal. Currently, due to the death of one of its members, there are only six TC members. Given the climate in which judicial decisions have become highly politicised, the necessary votes may not be forthcoming.

Congress is currently involved in selecting new members of the TC. Most of its current members should have retired, but Congress has repeatedly failed to appoint new ones.