The last week has been witnessed a case that appears to highlight the growing tendency to use legal and judicial mechanisms to browbeat investigative journalists in Peru, arguably undermining freedom of expression. On 10 January, journalist Christopher Acosta and his editor Jerónimo Pimentel Prieto, were given a two-year suspended prison sentence and 400,000 soles fine (approx. US$100,000) following the accusation of aggravated defamation brought by César Acuña, leader of the Alianza por el Progreso (APP) party.

The charges against them focused on 55 statements and third-party quotes in Acosta’s book “Plata como Cancha” that Acuña argued were defamatory. In sentencing, Judge Raúl Jesús Vega found 35 phrases he deemed to be “damaging to [the] honour and reputation” of Acuña. The publishing house, Penguin Random, was also included in the sentencing as a third party liable in this civil case.

Before establishing APP, which is one of the larger blocs in the present Congress, Acuña was mayor of the city of Trujillo, elected in 2006 and re-elected in 2010. In parallel, he controls a network of private universities. The first of these to be established was Universidad César Vallejo. He was a candidate in the 2016 presidential elections but was disqualified for allegedly vote buying. In the 2021 elections he came seventh.

The case against Acosta has resulted in a wave of criticisms about the way the law is being used effectively to muzzle investigative journalism in Peru.

Responding to the sentence, the president of the National Journalists Association (ANP) stated that “the instrumentalisation of justice has been tainting the journalistic profession for the past [several] years” and he feared that the sentence would create a dangerous precedent as no journalist will be able to use third party quotes or testimonies without the fear of being prosecuted or fined for defamation.

In a public statement, the ANP highlighted that there had been 104 demands for defamation against journalists in the past four years and insisted on the need to decriminalise defamation and crimes deemed to damage ‘the honour’ of those involved.

The Institute of the Press and Society (IPYS) also stated that the sentence demands the author in question to prove [the veracity] of what third party people said. This, it said, contradicts the position on such matters adopted by the Interamerican Commission on Human Rights.

The defence is to appeal the case.