International lawyers who are following the selection of new members of the Constitutional Tribunal (TC) have criticised the way in which candidates have been rejected without any explanation from the special congressional committee in charge.
On 16 December, the committee met to review 43 nominations that had been rejected. Days later it published the names of just five of the 43 whose names were finally approved to go forward. In addition, the panel of international jurists resolved to urge the congressional committee to take steps to achieve a more equal gender balance on the TC. Currently all the members of the TC are men.
The election of a new TC is of extreme importance given the number of controversies extant between the legislature and the executive, not least with respect to attempts by Congress to change the constitution to clip President Pedro Castillo’s wings by reducing executive powers.
The latest controversy centres on legislation by Congress that would eliminate the possibility of constitutional reforms being achieved by means of a popular initiative. The Congress is seeking to establish that it has the last word as to whether a reform proposal can prosper in this way. The executive has refused to promulgate the legislation, remitting it to Congress.
If Congress insists, it will be for the TC to decide whether it is constitutional or not. According to Francisco Eguiguren – a constitutional expert, former justice minister and former member of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights – the use of a popular initiative does not require congressional approval.
Recent Comments