In addition to the assassination of a series of environmental and human rights defenders over the last year, a logging company in the Madre de Dios region has obtained a court order against the president of the regional indigenous organisation for statements he made in defence of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation. An environmental journalist and government officials have also faced unsuccessful attempts to sue them.

In March 2007, the Interamerican Human Rights Commission (CIDH) announced precautionary measures in favour of the Mashco Piro indigenous people in voluntary isolation because of their vulnerability to activities by outsiders in their traditional territories. This measure obliged the Peruvian authorities to take measures to protect this ‘uncontacted’ group.

In June 2020, the president of the Madre de Dios regional indigenous federation (FENAMAD), Julio Cusirichi, privately expressed his concerns to the Ministry of Culture about the potential impacts of the Canales Tahuamano logging company on the Masco Piro as it resumed post-lockdown extractive activities.

In view of the lack of any response by the ministry, on 6 July FENAMAD denounced the entry of the logging company’s machinery and workers into the Masco Piro territory. On 9 July, it received on a notarial letter from the company requesting a public rectification. FENAMAD refused to comply.

On 5 October, the company presented a constitutional demand against the FENAMAD president for impugning the company’s honour and reputation. On 13 October, the writ was deemed admissible by the Superior Court in Madre de Dios which a day later ruled in favour of the company. It ordered FENAMAD to publish a letter withdrawing its accusation within two days and to pay a fine of 3,520soles (approximately US$900). The court also urged FENAMAD and Cusirichi to avoid such declarations in the future. On 29 November, the court confirmed this judgement. FENAMAD and Cusirichi are to appeal.

EarthRights International (ERI) has questioned this decision, considering it to be part of a strategy of judicial intimidation designed to silence those defending the rights of indigenous peoples in isolation. The Observatory for the Protection of Human Rights Defenders, a joint programme of the World Organisation Against Torture (OMCT) and the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH), has urged the Peruvian authorities to implement immediate measures to protect the rights of the Masco Piro. The Observatory considers that the sentence underscores the climate in which those defending human rights are deliberately intimidated through the undue use of constitutional, penal and administrative law against those who legitimately and peacefully defend human rights.

The second example involves the much criticised Peruvian cacao company Tamshi (formerly Cacao del Perú Norte) that has sued the journalist Yvette Sierra Praeli of the environmental newsletter Mongabay Latam for reporting on deforestation, as well as targeting others in what appears to be a similar pattern of intimidation. The lawsuit against Sierra Praeli was dismissed by the court in November.

A further lawsuit against four officials from the Ministry of the Environment (MINAM), including one who had unsuccessfully prosecuted a case against the company has been dropped, but may be appealed. Former Environment Minister Gabriel Quijandría, declared: “this is an unfortunate practice of intimidation against officials of the Ministry of the Environment who are simply doing their job in generating evidence about the crimes [committed by] these companies.”

In a third lawsuit, reported on by the PSG Newsletter in April, the forester and head of the NGO Kené, Lucila Pautrat, who published allegations made by against Tamshi by farmers, was given a two year suspended sentence and fine, against which she is appealing. Her lawyer has declared that “it is an act of intimidation [intended] to stop her publishing news of public interest”, adding: “a lousy precedent [is being set] for environmental rights and a very strong threat against environmental defenders in a country where environmental defenders have even been murdered.”