The Observatorio de Conflictos Mineros (a platform integrated by civil society organisations Cooperacción, Fedepaz and Cajamarca-based Grufides) published its 29th report on 14 December. It analyses the main trends and causes of social conflicts over mining during the second half of 2021. The report was presented at the Observatorio’s first presential press conference in over two years.

Ana Leyva, of Cooperacción, began by providing some contextual economic data. Peru, she said, will see a 10.6% GDP increase in 2021, better than many had expected. The IMF predicts growth of around 4.6% in 2022, more than in most of Latin America. This positive economic outcome, she asserted, is due in large part to the ongoing boom in metals prices, particularly copper. These respond to the growing demand for minerals needed for the world’s energy transition. Copper prices are up 44% over the past twelve months and account for around half of Peru’s minerals exports.

Leyva stated that 2021 has seen a slight reduction in the number of social conflicts, with the highest numbers concentrated in what she referred to as the ‘macro north’ and ‘macro south’. Of the 198 registered in October, 148 are categorised as ‘active’, seven are new. She pointed out that these are taking place in regions where voter support for President Pedro Castillo was particularly strong.

Most of the conflicts related to mining are in the southern ‘mining corridor’, with 42 in Cuzco, Puno, Apurímac and Ayacucho regions where some of the biggest mining concessions are located: Las Bambas in Apurímac, and both Antapaccay and Constancia in Cuzco. These, Leyva noted, are conflicts where communities are not fighting against mining activities as such, but where community expectations for local economic growth and development opportunities have been unmet. ‘Dialogue tables’ are in place in many of these instances.

Leyva argued that the institutional weakness of Peru’s central and local governments is one of the main factors exacerbating social conflict. At Las Bambas, for instance, the conflict was ignited by arbitrary changes made to the environmental impact assessment that allowed for a transport route that has caused huge problems for communities due to the dust and vibration caused by heavy trucks. There was no proper and effective oversight in place to evaluate the impact of these changes, or mitigation measures. “The system failed”, she said.

David Velazco from FEDEPAZ spoke about the criminalisation of social protest. The state, he noted, continues to prioritise the use of force and condones misuse of the legal system to address social protest instead of adopting dialogue to address the demands of local communities. He argued that the Castillo government has so far shown few clear signs of reversing this practice. He referred to last month’s events in Huarmey (in Ancash region) where judicial proceedings were opened against 58 people who had been protesting against the activities of Antamina.

Mirtha Villanueva, from Grufides, criticised the impact of artisanal and informal mining in regions such as Cajamarca. “The law allows them to register and state that they are in the process of being formalised so that they can continue doing what they want” she remarked, “a defender went to the authorities with a bottle of orange water to denounce his family’s ill health and that of his crops, denouncing informal mining activity, and then [suffered] repression. The people of Peru and Latin America are suffering from this perverse [development] model”, she said.

Also on the panel was Giselle Huamaní, secretary of the Office of Social Management and Dialogue at the Prime Minister’s Office (PCM). She agreed with the other panellists, stressing the frustration for local communities caused by unmet expectations and the lack of communication on the part of public institutions. She said that the new government is seeking to change the practices used hitherto and to ensure that conflicts are resolved through effective dialogue and improved institutional intervention.

She also spoke about the way in which issues were brought together in spaces for dialogue, many of longstanding. Some of these, she said, were “structural” and should be dealt with separately. These included issues such as the use of the canon and land titling. She noted just how difficult it is to build a climate of goodwill and to get communities to put their faith in dialogue.