In the end, it was not to be. On 7 December, Congress voted by a larger margin than once expected to oppose the attempt by the far right to initiate impeachment proceedings against President Pedro Castillo. For this to be admissible required the support of 40% of the plenary, or 52 votes. The resolution was defeated by 76 to 46 with four abstentions.
Those voting for impeachment proceedings to begin were the three far-right parties, Fuerza Popular, Renovación Popular and Avanza País. Together these have 43 seats in Congress. They managed to attract the support of two members from Alianza para el Progreso and one from Podemos Perú.
Last minute meetings with the leaders of other parties helped swing the balance in Castillo’s favour. Crucially, the ruling Perú Libre party voted en bloc against the resolution, following a meeting between Castillo and Vladimir Cerrón, the party’s leader and general secretary. Previously it had seemed possible that the sector closest to Cerrón would have voted for the resolution so as to avenge Castillo for the sacking of Guido Bellido as prime minister in October.
The refusal of the far-right party leaders to accept Castillo’s invitation to talks also possibly tilted the result in the president’s favour. Rather than a genuine attempt to negotiate in good faith, these parties seemed more interested in upsetting Peru’s fragile democracy than in reprimanding the president for alleged misdeeds. Of the three, Keiko Fujimori’s Fuerza Popular, the largest bloc, has repeatedly shown its unwillingness to accept defeat at the ballot box.
The result of the vote provides some relief for the embattled Castillo. Although it is almost certain that the three parties will again seek to push for impeachment – the only constitutional means of getting rid of a president – they may now bide their time, for a bit. Much will depend on whether the gaffe-prone Castillo manages to avoid giving them the opportunity to do so.
Comments made by some of those leaders who met with Castillo before the vote have given the impression that the president will shortly announce changes to his cabinet. However, they were cautious to avoid hinting that they would accept offers of cabinet positions. Most parties, with the exception of Juntos por el Perú, will want to avoid seeming complicit with a government that has rapidly lost popularity, not least with sub-national elections scheduled for next year.
Castillo faces the problem of appeasing parties on the centre-left and centre-right without burning bridges with Perú Libre on the left. Cerrón will seek to use his influence over the party to prevent a major shift to the right.
In the wake of the vote, Dina Boluarte, who as well as minister for social inclusion is also vice-president, announced that if, in the future, Castillo is impeached and therefore forced to resign, she would resign as vice-president. Were this to happen, the presidency of the republic would pass to the president of Congress, currently María del Carmen Alva, but with the proviso that she hold elections forthwith.
It remains unclear in the 1993 constitution (Article 115) whether such elections would be general elections (for both the presidency and Congress) or just for the presidency. The constitution simply says that there should be “elections”. Various constitutional experts have said that these would have to be general elections since the logic of the constitution is that the executive and legislature are co-terminous and that both are in office for a five-year period. This would mean that members of Congress would risk losing their seats.
However, such a reading would most likely end up with the Constitutional Tribunal. Congress is currently in the process of choosing new members to replace the six whose terms have already expired (one of whom died two months ago).
For its part, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights has expressed its concern about the lack of clear definition as to the grounds for impeachment. It says that this has serious implications for the separation of powers in Peru and the country’s democratic institutions. It is worried “about the repeated use of this procedure” and what this implies for democracy.
Recent Comments