The conflict continues between the Las Bambas mine, owned by MMG, and communities of Chumbivilcas, Cuzco. On 7 December, community, mine and government representatives met to negotiate a solution but failed to reach agreement.
Chumbivilcas leaders had requested that they supply 5% of the trucks for transporting copper ore as well as fifty other vans and 5% of minor paving maintenance contracts (having previously asked for 20%), but the company rejected the demand. The communities claim that the company is offering them an “an inferior and discriminatory price” compared to their interactions with other suppliers. They also want to meet with the mine’s general manager rather than just with people from the community relations office.
The communities’ demands are voiced in the context of changes brought about to mining plans for Las Bambas by successive governments. The previous owners of Las Bambas, Xstrata, did not include overland transportation of ore in their plans agreed in initial discussions with communities. This is because Xstrata would have piped the ore from Las Bambas to its already operative Tintaya mine in Espinar, Cuzco.
When MMG acquired the mine, these plans were dropped, and the then government allowed the company to transport ore overland instead. They did so without any changes to the Environmental Impact Assessment and without discussions with the affected communities. Rural communities were suddenly faced with a constant flow of heavy trucks pounding through their villages, causing significantly heightened pollution but bringing them no benefits.
The communities of Chumbivilcas also say that the land over which the road passes is communal land, and that there was no prior consultation over its use. They argue that they have a right to negotiate afresh.
MMG has confirmed that it will have to shut down the Las Bambas mine (responsible for around 2% of global copper production) until the disagreement is resolved. It says it will continue to meet its responsibilities to the communities. It attributes the impending closure to supply difficulties. It also faces disputes with other communities connected to the mine.
Fifteen associations and businesses from Challhuahuacho district (in Apurímac) met with officials from the Presidency of the Council of Ministers (PCM) to request an immediate resolution of the conflict. Other contractors of Las Bambas have also called for the blockade to end and for the national government to take action, claiming that it is an illegal strike that is affecting their rights to work and freedom of movement.
The National Society of Mining, Petroleum and Energy (SNMPE) stated that the cessation of production at las Bambas would put at risk over 8,000 jobs (half the workers live in Apurímac or Cuzco) and will generate large losses for suppliers and local governments.
As a result of the loss of local government income from the closure, the local mayors of Cotabambas have said that they will need to ask for US$196 million from central government, as compensation for lack of tax income. District governments in Cotabambas have also expressed concern that the disagreements with Chumbivilcas in Cuzco could affect tax income for communities in Apurímac.
These distinct positions between communities in different regions reflect the range of impacts that mining can have that are not reflected in legal definitions of the areas of influence of mines, and which often determine requirements for local mining tax receipts or other forms of compensation.
This means that some communities closer to mines, such as those in the areas of direct influence, receive increased tax receipts through the mining canon or community projects directly paid for by a mine, and can sometimes gain increased access to jobs. Meanwhile communities further away from a mine can still experience negative effects (such as mine-related pollution) but may not receive any benefits.
Recent Comments