In 22 October, the executive power lodged an appeal to the Constitutional Tribunal (TC) concerning a law, passed by Congress on 19 October, that seeks to limit the executive’s powers to dissolve the legislature via votes of confidence. The executive believes that the law is unconstitutional in that it seeks, unilaterally, to alter the balance of power between itself and the legislature. The executive also claims that a substantive reform to the constitution can only come about by the means prescribed in the constitution and not through ordinary legislation.
As presented, the law passed by Congress would only enable the executive to demand a vote of confidence in Congress on matters expressly pertaining to its own functions. It could not demand a vote of confidence on issues arising from those pertaining to the Congress. It thus seeks to amend Articles 132 and 133 of the 1993 constitution which lays out procedures for votes of confidence. According to Article 134, the executive can dissolve Congress if, within the five years of a presidential term, the Congress denies a vote of confidence more than once.
As well as spelling out this mechanism by which a president can dissolve Congress and demand a fresh legislative election, the 1993 constitution also contains the means by which Congress can get rid of a president through impeachment. This requires a two-thirds majority vote. The grounds for impeachment include the charge of ‘moral incapacity’, a vague concept but one invoked in November 2020 to force Martín Vizcarra out as president.
The vote on the bill to amend the grounds for demanding a vote of confidence was passed by 79 votes in favour to 43 against with three abstentions. The law was backed by the more conservative parties in Congress, including Fuerza Popular, Renovación Popular and Avanza País. The debate ignored a bill presented previously sent by the executive to Congress which sought to link the diminution in executive powers to an amendment of the rules governing ‘moral incapacity’. This had previously been agreed upon in the Acuerdo Nacional, a cross-party entity designed to build political consensus.
It is by no means certain that the TC will back the executive’s opposition to the law. Its verdict must carry the support of five of its members. Currently there are only six members of the tribunal following the recent death of one of their number. Hitherto, the tribunal has tended to side with the executive in its various fights with an opposition-dominated Congress anxious to increase its powers. In 2018 and again in 2019 the tribunal gave the executive favourable verdicts over the question of votes of confidence. While it may refer to these decisions, there is no guarantee that it will do so. Five of the six members of the TC are up for renewal, and appointments to the tribunal are a prerogative of the Congress.
In any case, the case may take some time to resolve. First the TC has to decide if the case is admissible or, in other words, whether it falls within its jurisdiction to deal with the matter. Then it will have to judge the merits of the case itself. The wheels of the justice system do not turn rapidly, although they may speed up if Congress successfully chooses new TC members to its taste (or at least to that of its conservative majority).
Meanwhile this coming week, on 25 October, the Vásquez cabinet will need to submit itself to a vote of confidence in Congress. On the left, the leadership of the ruling Perú Libre (PL) has said that it will vote against the cabinet in reprisal for the sacking of several ministers (headed by former prime minister Guido Bellido) in last week’s cabinet reshuffle. However, several PL members of Congress have said they will defy the position adopted by PL’s general secretary Vladimir Cerrón.
The willingness of Congress to approve the new cabinet may also depend on a strategic calculation that to oppose a motion of confidence so early on in a five-year term will restrict Congress’s room for manoeuvre later on in facing down the government, especially if the TC upholds the executive’s position in declaring the new law unconstitutional.
Recent Comments