A court in Nauta in the Loreto region has passed a historic sentence requiring that the usufruct portion of Amazonian community land titles be registered as full-fledged property and that free, prior and informed consent be required for granting easements to oil companies. This thus strengthens indigenous rights in line with ILO Convention 169. At the same time, the national government has canceled a major land titling project funded by the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB).
When ordering that a community’s lands be titled, the court in Nauta ruled that Article 11 of Law 22175 is unconstitutional, because it violates ILO Convention 169. Article 11 states that Amazonian indigenous communities are only entitled to usufruct rights to forest land, whereas they enjoy full property rights to land deemed suitable for other uses. This contrasts with treatment of Andean peasant communities who enjoy full rights to the property they receive in title.
The distinction has been a source of resentment amongst Amazonian indigenous communities since the 1970s. Most land titled for Amazonian communities is forest land.
The same sentence annulled easements granted to the Ministry of Energy and Mines for oil operations and required that they only be granted after the communities involved have given their free, prior and informed consent, also in conformity with ILO 169.
The lawsuit was presented by the indigenous federations comprising the PUINAMUDT Platform in association with NGOs Instituo de Defensa Legal del Ambiente y el Desarrollo Sostenible (IDLADS) and the Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL) with financial support from Oxfam.
The judge also ruled that financial payments associated with such easements or oil concessions be paid to the real owners of the lands, the indigenous communities, and not to the state, as has been the case up till now. The full sentence can be found here.
It is likely that this decision will be appealed to the Loreto superior court and may end up in the Constitutional Tribunal. If sustained at these higher levels in the judicial system, the rulings will represent a radical change. They will strengthen indigenous land rights, widen the application of ILO 169 in Peru, and channel substantial financial resources directly to indigenous communities.
It is to be expected that the rulings will be strongly contested both by sectors in the state and by the oil industry.
However, in a parallel but apparently unconnected development, the Ministry of Agricultural Development and Irrigation (Midagri) informed a delegation of indigenous leaders that a major IDB-funded state-run land titling project (PTRT3) had been suspended. This third stage in a long-running land titling project, funded jointly by the IDB and the Peruvian government under an agreement signed in 2015, has long been criticised for its high costs and scant results.
The project has been contracted out to a series of private consultants and has been the subject of accusations about unjustified expenditures. The head of the state land titling agency within Midagri, Pavel Álvares, is reported as stating that “PTRT3 has failed and has already spent 40 of the 80 million dollars assigned for this third stage”. Only six communities have been fully titled by the project in this period while there are 640 communities waiting to receive land titles.
The government has promised to continue titling using its own funds, but indigenous leaders oppose this because they believe that it implies they will have to wait another three years.
Recent Comments