There has been a six-fold increase in worldwide artisanal and small-scale gold mining (ASM) over the last five years. The ability to track what is going on has improved radically as in recent years there has been a marked increase in the extent and quality of worldwide satellite-based imagery in different wave-bands and of higher resolution, together with the ability to process such imagery, including the use of advanced AI techniques.

The policy issues are highlighted in a recent paper by Álvarez-Berríos et al. from the University of Wisconsin-Madison on ASM in the Madre de Dios region of Peru.

To the widely acknowledged difficulties of documentation and record keeping, as well as the lack of necessary support structures, the paper adds facts such as the way a ‘provisional’ mining concession is only too easily taken as full freedom to treat the land as belonging to the beneficiaries. Formalisation has been the key government policy adopted to attempt to manage the negative environmental and social effects associated with unregulated ASM.

The authors conclude that:

  • It may have been hoped that giving miners formal long-term mining concessions would encourage them to look after the land. However, this does not seem to have happened in practice. One reason is that mining concession holders are not necessarily those who mine it. Further, having a formal concession does not necessarily lead to miners complying with environmental regulations.
  • Enforcement is very patchy, and corruption attenuates the environmental benefits.
  • It is more difficult to delineate the concessions in the fluid and shifting Amazon ecosystem than in hard-rock mining in the sierra.
  • Alluvial mining is largely incompatible with conserving tropical forests.
  • The granting of land titles to indigenous communities in the Amazon, which Peru has agreed to under the ILO Convention 169, has not progressed well. Clarity in such rights is a precondition for proceeding towards achieving a functional mining concession.

For formalisation to work as intended, the rules and procedures need to be crafted in a way that takes fully into account the regional context and (conflicting) local and national agendas. The authors call for more explicit and context-specific attention to the mechanisms by which formalisation might improve environmental outcomes.