A report written by Rocío Arana and Keyla Barrero and promoted by the Forest Peoples Programme, the Lowenstein International Human Rights Clinic at Yale University Law School and Middlesex University analyses the situation of social and environmental protection of indigenous peoples in the Peruvian Amazon during the Covid-19 pandemic. Its conclusions are damning.

The report describes the actions and omissions of the state in protecting indigenous rights. As well as a memoir of such failings, it is also a record of the initiatives taken by indigenous peoples in protecting their rights and reducing the risks of harm they faced.

In the prologue, the anthropologist Federica Barclay claims that “the state has been incapable of developing effective systems of prevention and attention to health precisely because it has resisted every effort by civil society and, in this case, by indigenous organisations to participate in their implementation and supervision”.

Furthermore, she adds, “almost nine months after the declaration of the state of emergency, the only systematic responses in the indigenous territories have been those carried out by the indigenous societies themselves, employing their traditional knowledge and their memory of the great epidemics they have confronted without help in the past.”

The report describes state policies as seeking to reactivate the economy without taking into account the medium- and long-term impacts on the lives, health and rights of indigenous peoples. It identifies five aspects in which the collective rights of indigenous peoples have been affected: (i) state policy towards indigenous peoples as whole; (ii) the ability to regulate and oversee business activity; (iii) failure to prevent the advance of illegal activities; (iv) response to the increased risks faced by indigenous and environmental rights defenders; and (v) the continued deforestation in the Amazon rainforest.

It argues that state measures affecting indigenous people have been largely negative in their impact. They have included the easing of environmental protection, specific initiatives emanating from both the executive and Congress to the detriment of indigenous peoples, failure to enforce existing laws and regulations and failure to rein in illegal activities.

The report concludes by contrasting this record with the results achieved by indigenous peoples themselves. Not only have they managed to confront the crisis generated by the pandemic but have dealt with environmental emergencies and invasions of their territory. They have also managed to oblige the state to enter into dialogue over policy implementation.