Electoral debate on economic issues has been, perhaps understandably, focused on the short-term measures needed to reboot economic activity and to rescue Peru from the deep recession caused by Covid-19 and its effects. But even the most short-term measures have longer-term impacts.
Proposals from the conservative camp since the first round on 11 April have emphasised the need to launch three or four largescale mining projects as the way to jump-start the economy. In general, thinking prioritises the export sector – including within it agribusiness, oil, and fisheries – as the driver of reactivation.
On the other side of the electoral divide, leftist proposals have emphasised the reactivation of the internal market via cash transfers, soft loans, and public investment in small-scale and labour-intensive infrastructure. Here the accent is on jobs and responding to the needs of small and medium-size enterprises.
These two different approaches will probably continue to sustain campaign discourses and proposals up until 6 June. After that, whoever wins will have to finetune the policies on offer and engage in the inevitable debate about longer-term needs.
The Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) has now joined the debate with a new publication entitled ‘Peru: oportunidades para la recuperación y el crecimiento sostenible y resiliente’. It calls for increased productivity in all sectors, guarantees that new investments are environmentally sustainable, and for institutional reforms to improve governance. The three, it argues, are critical if we want ‘to build back better’, not just rebuild the same.
In Peru, over 70% of the economy is informal and dominated by small-scale production, trade and service provision, with very low levels of productivity. Mining and oil, along with banking and financial services, are at the other end of the scale; they generate few jobs but enjoy high productivity.
Peru is highly biodiverse but suffers from water stress, deforestation, and the loss biodiversity . These are due to unsustainable economic activities and patterns of urbanisation as well as to the impact of global warming. Public education and health are (in principle) universal but lack the resources to ensure quality services. Too many still lack access to public sanitation. Tax pressure is low and highly regressive, and public budget management is inefficient.
The IDB offers proposals to address these mid- to long-term challenges. One may agree or disagree with them, but they are certainly a welcome contribution. Although Peru badly needs a quick economic recovery, thought needs to be devoted towards moving away from being an informal/low productivity economy that fails to generate decent jobs and the public revenues needed to provide good basic services for all in ways that are environmentally sustainable.
Let’s hope the two candidates take stock of such proposals and let’s hope that whoever wins adjusts their own agenda to responding to the structural and longer-term challenges.
Recent Comments