For most of us, nationalisation means the takeover of private interests by the state or a state company. This is what nationalisation used to mean when Peruvian and foreign firms were taken over in the 1970s during the Velasco government (1968-75). Many were subsequently privatised 20 years later during the governments of Alberto Fujimori (1990-2000).
However, the idea of ‘nationalisation’ appears to have shifted in its meaning. According to José de Echave, it no longer means being taken into state ownership (‘estatización’) but rather reformed in such a way as to aid national development.
De Echave, the founder of Cooperacción and one of Verónika Mendoza’s vice-presidential running mates on the Juntos por el Perú (JPP) ticket, is likely to be an influential voice in the design of policy towards extractive industries in the case of Pedro Castillo becoming Peru’s next president. As we surmised last week, the JPP policy team may be a valuable resource to a Castillo government otherwise bereft of people with policy experience. De Echave was vice-minister for the environment during the government of Ollanta Humala.
In an interview published in La República last week, de Echave commented that “a prime task is to confront the spectre that nationalisation is the same as taking things into state ownership, to say that the extractive sectors [of the economy] are going to be replete with public companies. When we talk about nationalisation, we are suggesting how those natural resources, those gifts of nature bestowed on us, are used in ways that clearly promote national development”.
He went on to use natural gas as an example, citing the cases of Colombia and Bolivia where gas is used to benefit consumers. In Peru, by contrast, part of what is produced from Camisea is exported, while a proposed gas pipeline linking Camisea with the cities of southern Peru has been mothballed.
With respect to mining, he is quoted as saying that nationalisation means “thinking how to ensure that the extractive surplus (renta) stays in a larger proportion within the country in order to finance its needs, particularly in a context like the present one in which prices are a beginning to rise in a significant way”. He says that the design of mining royalties needs to change and the high profits derived from windfall prices need to be taxed.
In the interview he is also critical of the suggestion made by Keiko Fujimori that 40% of the mining canon – the percentage of corporate mining taxes that is channelled to sub-national tiers of government—should be allocated to affected communities as a policy that “hasn’t been properly thought through”. He sees a number of snags to such a scheme, including depriving regional and municipal governments of the funds they require to finance their activities. He cites the example of Espinar in Cuzco where, in 2019, the mining canon provided 71% of the provincial government’s revenue.
Recent Comments