On 25 January 2019 the tailings dam at the Brazilian Vale mine at Brumadinho (also known as Córrego do Feijão) failed catastrophically, killing 270 people. This followed the failure of another Vale tailings dam on 5 November 2015 at the Mariana mine (also known as Bento Rodrigues or Samarco) killing 19 people.

Following these disasters there was renewed worldwide activity to investigate the cause and to put in place governance practices, inspections and mechanisms to stop such disasters in the future. In particular a group of NGOs and the UN Environment Program then set up a study. This group requested information from 727 companies and 339 responded.

After analysing data received from the companies, the group has now issued a report on its findings. The report notes that “10 per cent of tailings facilities reported notable stability concerns or failure to be confirmed or certified as stable at some point in their history”. It analyses different construction methods and notes that “that upstream facilities can theoretically be built safely under the right circumstances”. However, it also notes that “our findings reveal that in practice active upstream facilities report a higher incidence of stability issues (18.3%) than other facility types, and that this elevated risk persists even when these facilities are built in high governance settings.” It should be noted that Peru had already banned the use of upstream dams.

More information on the mines and the tailing facilities, including many in Peru, can be found in Supplementary information 1 and Supplementary information 2.