As Peru faces the second wave of the Covid-19 pandemic, the Defensoría del Pueblo has published two reports on state policy towards indigenous peoples during the health emergency last year: one focusing on the indigenous peoples’ participation in the emergency and the other on the measures taken by the state to safeguard their health.
The report on the participation of indigenous peoples concludes that, when the pandemic began, the state lacked mechanisms for indigenous participation in the battle against Covid, although eventually – in response to initiatives from indigenous peoples and their civil society allies – spaces for indigenous representation were created. The most important of these was the national Multisectoral Commission in which indigenous representatives presented their needs and demands and the relevant ministries reported back on their activities.
At the regional level – again at the initiative of indigenous organizations – Covid Commands were formed in nine regions to facilitate implementation of the health ministry’s Amazonian emergency plan. However, their actions were hampered by the lack of specifically assigned funding from regional governments for supervision, follow-up and monitoring.
Despite these advances, the Defensoría notes that indigenous representatives complain that they were excluded from decisions about how to allocate funds associated with the Amazon Health Plan and were informed only when decisions had been made. Furthermore, indigenous women were underrepresented. The report makes specific recommendations about improving effective coordination between the state and indigenous peoples at the national, regional and local levels.
The second report on the actions of the state in defence of indigenous health during the coronavirus emergency observes that at the beginning of the pandemic the state failed to respond to the specific needs of indigenous peoples. Only after two months and persistent advocacy by indigenous leaders was Decree Law No. 1489 passed, creating the Amazonian emergency health plan and incorporating a differentiated strategy. The Defensoría claims that staff in regional and local governments still need to be better informed about the Plan, which has yet to be disseminated in indigenous languages.
The Plan has still not been fully implemented and has failed to reach all indigenous communities. The Defensoría notes an inadequate response to the increase in the number of cases of infection, the lack of health personnel, the closure of many health posts due to the contagion among health staff, the ongoing shortage of essential medicines, and the chronic lack of equipment.
The measures to provide food and financial assistance to poor families initially lacked protocols to protect communities in voluntary confinement. There is still no guarantee that they are being effectively enforced.
During the initial months of the emergency the national and regional authorities did not think to include the ethnic dimension in their administrative reports and official information, a gap in the data that was not remedied until the end of May. At the national level, the Centre for Epidemiology and Disease Prevention and Control lacked information about the impact of the pandemic on indigenous peoples until pressed by the Defensoría and indigenous leaders. At the regional level, 20 of the country’s 25 regions still do not include ethnic identification and language in their reports.
In August, the health ministry created an information centre on the indigenous population with Covid-19 which produces periodic reports that fail to provide a breakdown by age and gender. As well as data on individuals, information is required about the collective impact on indigenous peoples.
In general, the Defensoría paints a picture of a precarious health system unable to respond rapidly to the increasing number of Covid cases. Nor is the state able to provide consistent healthcare to indigenous peoples in border areas vulnerable to contagion from Ecuador, Brazil or Colombia.
Both reports concur in describing a situation where, at the beginning of the pandemic, the specific needs of indigenous people were invisible to the authorities. It took persistent advocacy by indigenous leaders and their allies for the state to respond by developing channels for participation and a health plan oriented to their needs.
The precarious state of the health system in general and the lack of adequate training and preparation of personnel for interacting appropriately with indigenous peoples mean that the effective implementation of measures is still very weak.
Recent Comments