The negative impact of Covid-19 on public finances makes the case for radical tax reform in Peru ever more urgent. With the fiscal deficit likely to hit nearly 10% of GDP this year, the government cannot, at least in the medium and longer term, continue without raising the country’s tax threshold.
The short-term response to this fiscal imbalance has been to borrow on the international bond markets. Peru’s reasonably positive credit rating – the credit rating agencies like Moody’s and Standard and Poors have long lauded Peru’s predilection for neoliberal economic policies – has made this the easier option.
Peru’s relatively low foreign debt in relation to GDP has made it possible to borrow with relative ease. At the end of September this stood at 32.1% of GDP according to Central Bank figures, a considerable increase on 23.9% two years previously. Both the IMF and the OECD (where Peru still aspires to full membership) advocate spending to overcome the social and economic ills caused by Covid-19. However, borrowing has its limits.
In a recent publication, the director of the OECD’s Centre for Tax Policy and Administration, Pascal Saint-Amans argues that beyond the short term, new forms of taxation will need to be tapped. He writes “the taxation of property and personal capital income will have an important role to play, particularly in the context of significant improvements in international tax transparency”.
Peru’s tax take was just 14.8% of GDP in 2019. Since then, reflecting the fall in people’s incomes and purchasing capacity, it stood at 11.6% of GDP at the end of the third quarter of 2020. According to the OECD, the average for Latin America and the Caribbean in 2018 (the latest date for available comparable statistics) was 23.1%, with Peru close to the bottom, while the average for OECD member countries was 34.3%. Meanwhile government spending has risen substantially because of Covid-19.
There has been debate in the election campaign about the need to put more emphasis on direct taxation, including the introduction of wealth taxes: taxes on assets, on inheritances or real estate. Peru derives very little from any of these sources. Again, according to the OECD, Peru’s dependence on indirect taxes (VAT etc.) in 2018 was the highest (40.3%) of any Latin American or Caribbean country.
In the context of Covid, some countries are grasping the nettle of wealth taxation. This is the case, for example, in Argentina, Colombia and Uruguay which all have wealth taxes or levies on capital. Brazil and Chile have ramped up inheritance taxes.
The arguments against such measures have traditionally been that they would simply encourage capital flight (or other forms of evasion) and that there would be less money available for domestic investment. Where the need for tax reform is discussed, it usually takes the form of trying to reduce tax evasion.
The impact of Covid-19 in Latin America is challenging such assumptions. Even the OECD is arguing the need for more progressive systems of taxation both for fiscal and redistributive reasons. Without more solidly funded states, the evident deficiencies in public services (such as public health) represent a danger to stability, let alone improvements in international competitiveness.
Arguably, since relatively some wealthier sectors of society have benefitted from the crisis whereas poorer sectors have been hit much harder, taxes on income and wealth should precede any increased tax on consumption.
Recent Comments