The continuing protest of the Chalhuahuacho communities over the lack of income from the canon and the Las Bambas project reached its next marker last week with the promised ‘technical commission’ reporting to the many base groups and organisations involved on the working of the canon. The report was presented in a meeting on 20 January.
The event has a peculiar interest as it illuminates the difficulty of managing expectations around the canon. The canon is the mechanism through which taxes on company profits are distributed to the region and locality in which mining takes place. As we explained earlier, communities look forward to receiving the rewards of the canon and are given to understand that 50% of taxes on profits will come to their local area and be distributed among the various actors.
So far, in the area around Las Bambas in Apurímac region, no revenue from this source has been received. What the communities have difficulty appreciating is that the way profits get reported – this is an incentive to investment – allows very low declarations of profit in the early years of a mine’s operations. This explains why mining’s percentage contribution to public revenue has fallen in recent years, well before Covid affected activity.
No-one seems to have realised the danger of awakened expectations. What is sharpening discontent in this case is that negotiations between the company and the government over a second mine in neighbouring Huancuire look likely to end up postponing payments of income tax even further – into 2023.
The communities had agreed in December to suspend the roadblocks which were damaging the movement of copper concentrate, while negotiations continued. We have yet to see whether the fresh understanding provided by the report will persuade the communities to reduce their opposition and to refrain from further protest.
The situation raises fundamental issues. Why should the local area be automatically entitled to a half share of tax on profits anyway? A less automatic mechanism, based in regional development needs, above all on poverty and lack of infrastructure, would be more rational but would require legislative action impossible in the short term.
Recent Comments