Three things over the last few weeks have pushed the issue of constitutional reform up the political agenda: the massive street demonstrations against the impeachment of Martin Vizcarra, the impact of the 25 October referendum in Chile, and the refusal of the Peru’s Constitutional Tribunal to interpret what is meant by “permanent moral incapacity”.
Veronika Mendoza has been among the first to run with the demand for constitutional reform in launching her bid for the presidency for Juntos por el Perú. She is proposing a consultative vote to coincide with next April’s election to see if there is public support for a renewal of the constitution. She is also demanding a new deal for agriculture and for Peru’s rural population.
Not to be outdone, Julio Guzmán, the likely candidate for the Partido Morado, has also advocated the need for constitutional reforms. So too has President Francisco Sagasti.
The present constitution dates from 1993. It was devised by a legislature elected the previous year in the wake of the April 1992 autogolpe by then President Alberto Fujimori. Ratified by a slim majority in a referendum, it sought to enable Fujimori to stand for re-election (a clause subsequently rescinded) and to raise into constitutional law the principles of neoliberalism fervently espoused by the Fujimori administration.
The 1993 constitution replaced that of 1979, a document that set the framework for Peru’s transition from military rule and highlighted a number of social rights and state duties which were removed by Fujimori’s favoured text.
It is these aspects, in particular, that Mendoza and the Left seek to challenge. With the return to a more interventionist state becoming ever more clearly the rule as a consequence of the Covid-19 pandemic, the 1993 constitution’s focus on the rights and privileges of the private sector is increasingly viewed as outdated.
When and how the 1993 constitution will be changed will depend greatly on the outcome of the general election next year. But between now and then, the Peruvian public will be watching to see how the reform of the 1980 Chilean constitution – similarly devised by General Augusto Pinochet to lock in the neoliberal model – progresses.
The date of the Chilean election to a Constituent Assembly has been fixed for 11 April 2021, the same day as the Peruvian elections. The Chilean assembly will have nine months to produce a new constitutional text. Will Peru follow suit?
Article 206 of the 1993 constitution specifies the way in which constitutional change can be brought about. Any change requires an absolute majority of votes in Congress and ratification by referendum. The referendum may be omitted if there are two votes in successive legislatures passed by a two-thirds majority. It seems unlikely that the current Congress will vote by such a margin as to enable constitutional reform to begin.
Recent Comments