The Constitutional Tribunal (TC) has failed to resolve the issue put to it by Martin Vizcarra as to whether Congress acted correctly in invoking ‘permanent moral incapacity’ as the pretext to remove him from office.
In a four-to-three decision, it refrained from offering an opinion on the matter. The president of the TC, Marianella Ledesma had argued that the case put before the tribunal was valid. In the end, four members – Ernesto Blume, Augusto Ferrero, José Luis Sardón and Manuel Miranda – opted not to resolve the case. They did so with the argument that the result (Vizcarra’s impeachment) was a fait accompli.
This means that ‘permanent moral incapacity’ can in future be used by Congress as a way of removing presidents of the republic, whether the current holder of the office or his successors. Article 113 of the 1993 constitution specifies this as one of the pretexts for such removal. Impeachment requires the support of two-thirds of Congress, 87 votes in favour. Vizcarra was removed with 105 votes.
It has been argued that the TC has failed in its duty to provide an interpretation of the constitution on this matter.
Recent Comments