The dialogue table (mesa de diálogo) at Las Bambas, the huge copper mine at Cotabambas now owned by the Chinese MMG, is proving hard work. It was only to be expected.

The latest incident involving the company and communities concerns the claim by the community of Huancuire that, following the sale of land to the company, 132 acres of its pastureland had been “usurped” since, as community land, it was not available for sale.

The case was made in Cuzco a month ago, and the community felt it failed to get backing from the authorities, specifically from OEFA, the environmental watchdog, which it accuses of siding with the company. Following this, the community feared it would be dislodged from the land by force. This seems to have happened on 17 November, when six community members were grazing their animals and 30 police and others arrived. They arrived “in uniform and with white helmets”. Of the six comuneros, four fled but two women thereupon disappeared. Their whereabouts were still unknown at the end of last week. Various protests and confrontations have followed, resulting in some comuneros being wounded. The company claims that two vehicles were burned.

The community claims that those who attacked them included ‘Venezuelans’ working with the police force. This seems to have been a further aggravating factor.

A second cause of tension concerns receipts from the canon. Before he left office, Luis Miguel Incháustegui, the former minister of energy and mines, made two visits in person to the area, on 2 and 16 October. The main topic he focussed on was the payments due from the canon, which the local defence front – the Frente de Defensa y Desarrollo de los Intereses de Apurímac — claims have been zero, despite operations at Las Bambas starting in 2016. He tried to present the correct figures, which show modest royalty payments.

The heart of the issue is the tax benefits that the company enjoys under the current legislation, which allows them to offset depreciation expenses against profits. Despite Incháustegui’s intervention, the Frente still sent a letter to Vizcarra on 3 November explaining the reasons for their distrust, accusing the state of “prostrating” itself before the company.

The current atmosphere seems unpropitious for constructive dialogue, although the need to talk is clearly pressing.