On 20 October, in an extraordinary session, the Congressional Foreign Affairs Commission decided (by nine votes to three) effectively to put an end to further deliberations and to vote down any chances of ratifying the Escazú Agreement. It thus shelved the recommendation put to it by the executive to approve Escazú.
The regional agreement, of which Peru had been a key advocate when it was first negotiated, aims to strengthen the defence of human and environmental rights. It is the first regional instrument to set out a series of standards to govern environmental human rights, such as the right to information, public participation, and access to justice on environmental matters. The agreement also included, importantly, the protection of environmental human rights defenders.
There has been a recent backlash of ‘fake news’ against ratification that suggested that it would weaken Peru’s sovereignty, an argument repeatedly refuted by civil society organisations and international lawyers alike. Lawyers argued that Escazú does not aim to control the natural resources of the Amazon region as its adversaries have suggested, nor does it seek to deny that states exercise sovereignty over these.
The parties in Congress opposing ratification were Fuerza Popular, Acción Popular, Podemos Perú, FREPAP, Alianza por el Progreso and Unidos por el Perú. They argued that Peru already enjoys the environmental legislation that Escazú asks for as well as having an effective justice system.
Following the decision, Aida Gamboa, coordinator of the Amazonia Programme at DAR, said that “We, as civil society, hand-in-hand with indigenous organisations, have been supporting this process. By shelving the Escazú Agreement, members of Congress have turned their backs on their citizens, on indigenous organisations, indigenous communities and environmental human rights defenders…”.
However, latest reports suggest it is unclear whether Congress’s decision is entirely above board. When the debate took place, a minority resolution (dictamen de minoría) was tabled that recommended ratification. According to Congresswoman Rocío Silva, the congressional rules establish that where there is a minority resolution, the majority one cannot be taken as final. Instead, both resolutions have to be discussed in a plenary session of Congress.
A request to reconsider the decision and to have a new vote was turned down on 23 October.
The Escazú Agreement was signed by 22 countries from Latin America and the Caribbean in 2018. It needs eleven ratifications to come into force. To date, it has ten. Argentina has been the latest country to ratify it.
Recent Comments