The following is an invited contribution from Ariela Ruiz-Caro, one of the panelists in the third PSG webinar. That webinar opened up the topic of the role of the state in Peru and the possible need to reconsider the economic chapter of the 1993 constitution.
The pandemic has exposed a dramatic reality in Peru, a health system that is one of the weakest in the continent. It has also re-opened the much-discussed question of the role and competences of the state and its relations with the private sector.
There are many issues embedded within this, not least the reality of a poorly functioning public sector. Corruption is a major contributory issue here, as is the history of unsatisfactory attempts to decentralise state responsibilities given deficient capacities at the local level.
An aspect of this discussion often set aside is the way in which the role of the state is embedded in the present constitution, enacted in 1993 by the Fujimori government precisely to limit state responsibilities. Hence it is worth us understanding what the constitution says about what the state can (or cannot) do.
The role of the state today is shaped by the economic chapter of the 1993 constitution which, reformulated that of 1979 – considered by its critics as excessively ‘statist’. The main articles of the economic chapter addressed the following aspects:
- The role of the Central Reserve Bank of Peru (BCRP) is limited to maintaining monetary stability while the goal of full employment is set aside. Likewise, BCRP financing of the Treasury is prohibited (Article 84), a measure designed to help control inflation and the fiscal deficit. But it permits the neglect of structural reform.
- The Constitution establishes the sanctity of so-called ‘contratos ley’. These provide legal and tax stability to contracts signed between the state and private parties. These cannot be modified by Congress, even in the event of changes in circumstances; they can only be amended through arbitration or a court (Article 62). This gives huge power to private companies. For example, if in a hydrocarbon license agreement the state changes the destination of the gas (paying the price agreed in the contract), the licensee can refuse to apply it. Of course, the licencee could agree and, indeed, at the instigation of private parties, investment contracts in energy, infrastructure and other sectors have often been modified. Such addenda to contracts were not always fair and the bidding rules were often modified, resulting in huge cost overruns that produced higher profits for the winner of the award and consequent increases in treasury expenditures. The change in the bidding rules has also been a window for corrupt authorities at all levels, including presidents, the most emblematic examples being revealed by the Lava Jato case.
- National and foreign investments are subject to the same conditions (Article 63). This reinforces the evident inequality in political weight in favour of foreign investment, as most local investors lack the economic and financial backing at the disposal of international firms.
- The constitution gives the state a subsidiary role in business activity. Article 60 establishes that the state can only carry out business activity if expressly authorised by law and for reasons of manifest public or national interest. This contrasts with Article 113 of the 1979 Constitution, which affirmed that the state could carry out business activity in the interests of providing public services and promoting national development.
While true that providing welfare or social benefit (education, health social security etc.) does not qualify as ‘business activity’, the state has given priority to achieving good risk ratings from global financial institutions at the expense of failing to invest adequately in social and other services. Spending on health is one of the lowest in the region and this explains the precarious nature of primary healthcare and lack of hospital capacity made manifest by the Covid-19 pandemic. In education, Peru came last in the latest PISA tests, conducted in 2018, among counties in Latin America. Since the state does not invest sufficiently in public services, access to quality education and health have ceased to be rights and have become business activities. First-world health and education services are available for some with the resources to acquire them while the vast majority of people have to make do with precarious and sub-standard provision.
Leaving the state to engage in activities that are not profitable to the private sector does not work to the benefit of society as a whole. The state cannot leave the totality of economic activity to the free play of private economic agents. There are certain sectors that require economic intervention to achieve equitable development. This is the case of public transport which cannot just be regulated by the laws of the market. It is necessary to plan routes and include some that are not profitable. The criterion must be to have an efficient and safe public service for the population as a whole, with the appropriate low environmental impact. Regulation may sometimes be a better answer than direct public ownership, but regulation in Peru has proved deficient over the years. But an open assessment of the alternatives is important.
Public health has suffered badly. Peru is second in the ranking of countries in Latin America with tuberculosis, third (after Haiti and Bolivia) with the highest rates of childhood anaemia (34%), and is among the seven countries with the highest levels of chronic childhood malnutrition (15%). In the field of housing, overcrowding is the norm in the slums of Lima and other cities. A quarter of the population lacks running drinking water and only 48% has a refrigerator.
A radical rethink is required in priorities if Peru’s deficient performance in basic human welfare is to be challenged. A place to begin is with the constitution which sets the framework in which political choices are made. It is striking just how few of the 23 parties registered for next April’s elections advocate the need for this sort of change.
Recent Comments