Mining companies habitually stress the importance of the sector’s tax contribution to justify all kinds of fiscal, environmental and social measures designed to promote investments in the sector. They successfully lobbied the government to declare it a priority sector to enable it to work when the rest of the country went into severe Covid-19 lockdown. They have also demanded to be considered ‘strategic’ for the purposes of mid- and longer-term economic reactivation and development.

According to figures published by Cooperacción, mining was indeed a very significant contributor to tax income during the so-called ‘commodities super-cycle’. In 2006 and 2007, the sector accounted for 20.9% and 24.7% respectively of all internal tax collection, and 44% and 50.9% of all corporate income tax.

But as the super-cycle dwindled and prices retreated in the face of lower external demand, the sector’s relative fiscal importance decreased too. By 2016, this had fallen to 5.4% of all tax paid and only 4.9% of corporate income tax payments. Despite a rebound in 2017 and 2018, the sector’s contribution had fallen further by the time the Covid-19 pandemic hit Peru at the beginning of this year.

And if the perspectives of a slow post-Covid global economic recovery – and only moderate growth in China – turn out to be true, the epoch in which mining companies could claim that Peru’s economy is dependent on them will not return any time soon.

Still, the sector’s fiscal contributions could have been – and could be in the future – more important, if it were not for the tax benefits that companies have enjoyed since the 1990s.

The Grupo de Justicia Fiscal has shown how these benefits have increased steadily over the last decade. Today, they are worth, for example, more than the entire budget allocated to public order and almost three times the sum allocated to social protection. Regarding the mining sector, Cooperacción suggests that in 2019 mining companies were given back 50% of what they contributed, and that this figure will rise to around 70% this year. In 2016 and 2017 mining companies actually took back in tax devolutions more than they paid in income tax.

Mining companies should therefore pay their fair share of tax, and the system by which exonerations are given needs revision. But for an informed decision to be taken regarding whether to maintain, reform or eliminate some (or all) of these, much more information needs to be placed in the public domain. Transparency here is of the upmost importance.