The Pandemic and its Impact on Indigenous People

 

Panellists:

  • Stephanie Boyd: journalist and filmmaker, who has worked on several films in Peru, including a recent indigenous-made ground-breaking film about the Covid-19 pandemic in the Amazon.
  • Lizardo Cauper: president of the Asociación Interétnica de Desarrollo de la Selva Peruana, AIDESEP.
  • Peter Hughes: Columban missionary priest and coordinator of Human and Territorial Rights in the Amazon in REPAM, a Catholic Church network promoting the lives and dignity of peoples living across Amazonia.
  • Carlos Soria: environmental lawyer, teacher and researcher at the Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú.

Moderator:

  • Vanessa Baird: PSG steering committee member; co-editor and co-director of the New Internationalist.

The session began with a brief extract from an indigenous-made video put together by Stephanie, showing the brutal reality of COVID in the Amazon region, as doctors and medical practitioners died and the health system collapsed. Despite the fact that the Peruvian constitution protects the health of all, the government has had no idea how to operate in the reality of the rural world of Peru. Health technicians would arrive and stay locked in their health posts without medicines. Indigenous communities realised very early that the bureaucratic and ill-informed state was not going to provide adequately and the only hope was self-provisioning.

The panel agreed that government intervention, rather than protecting health and controlling the virus, had encouraged its spread amongst the indigenous population. Where indigenous authorities closed the frontiers of their territories, the spread of Covid proved manageable but where civil and military authorities disputed their right to do so, the virus spread more quickly. Peru’s formal governmental system refuses to recognise indigenous peoples’ definition of their frontiers. Extractive companies were officially allowed by the government to bring in workers from outside the area, breaking the rules set up by the communities.

The most telling anecdote concerned the arrival of a navy boat on one of the region’s rivers, the river Napo, bringing ‘help’ and insisting that everyone stay in their houses. The local leaders explained that they were already in firm community lockdown. They were observing their borders rigorously with people able to pursue their livelihoods within those confines. The military on the boat would not accept this, and infections resulted.

The Catholic Church’s synod on the Amazon, held last October 2019, was a major event in listening, with 87,000 people taking part in the preliminary consultations. For the organisers – Peter Hughes being one of them – it had been a powerful experience of listening. But the Peruvian authorities neglected the lesson and did not listen as the crisis mounted.

The panel emphasized a theme that will be developed more fully in the next webinar when we discuss the challenges of the economic recovery: the impact of the extractive industries. Government encouragement for an early restoration of oil and gas production in the Amazon gave Covid additional vigour, spreading the virus further amongst the indigenous population. The decision brought protests that resulted in fatal confrontations with the police guarding oil installations on indigenous lands. The pandemic has seen an increase in deaths of environmental defenders. As Lizardo Cauper put it, “We asked President Vizcarra to send us medicine, but he sent us police”.

Another theme was land titling, of enormous importance to safeguard the rights of indigenous communities. Lockdown has made the slow progress on this far slower, since government offices are closed and the necessary detailed surveys and measurements on the ground are not possible. Funding for land titling for communities has been difficult to secure, eg from the InterAmerican Development Bank.

The hope? For the panel this lay in the community response once the nature of the crisis was understood and the lack of outside help made manifest. People caught away from their community when the crisis occurred, were made to stay away, or return via isolation centres the people set up. To treat the symptoms of Covid and help boost their immune systems, indigenous peoples have relied on traditional herbal medicine and their own practitioners. In Ucayali, volunteers bottled and distributed herbal beverages. The Federation of Kukama Women established a radio network of correspondents to connect communities. In Iquitos, the church raised enough money through crowdfunding to provide an oxygen machine which the state had failed to provide. The ‘collective quarantine’ was a healthy community response. And the whole awful experience has at the least allowed indigenous people to learn more of what the outside world is, and – maybe – allowed the outside world better to understand indigenous peoples, their livelihoods and the context in which they live and their role in defending the environment of the Amazon, with its implications for climate change.

Finally, the panel was asked to reflect on the priority right now.

  • From Stephanie Boyd: we need to recognise that we are still in the middle of a health crisis. Food and medicines are needed. The government needs to sit down and talk leadership to leadership. This is an opportunity to right a huge historical wrong.
  • From Peter Hughes: the international context right now is very unhelpful. The priority is to keep focused on the struggle for rights.
  • From Lizardo Cauper: the government needs to reflect on what has happened, be responsive, provide a dedicated budget. “The rainforest is crying” – international pressure is important.
  • From Carlos Soria: Good use of legal actions around rights can be a way of spreading understanding.

And what can people outside Peru do to stand alongside the indigenous peoples of the Amazon?

  • Campaign on divestment from fossil fuels and minerals in pension funds and the like.
  • Spread the word about the reality of Peru – via the Peru Support Group or other means.
  • Street protest is useful but work on investors should go alongside.
  • Lobby for high level support for action – pressure from the EU can help.
  • Re-think rural health policy.
  • Draw attention to rising violence against women during lockdown.
  • Keep attention on alluvial mining and trafficking of women and girls, which has continued during the pandemic.
  • Recognise that markets for indigenous products have collapsed with lockdown, and support will be needed.
  • We need to change our mindset – value the Amazon, which supplies 20% of the world’s drinking water, re-educate ourselves.