The second of five PSG webinars took place on Saturday, 26 September. The topic was ‘The Pandemic and its Impact on Indigenous People’ and the four panellists were:

  • Stephanie Boyd: filmmaker and journalist, who has produced a series of films on the Amazon region, including a ground-breaking film about the Covid-19 pandemic.
  • Lizardo Cauper: president of the Asociación Interétnica de Desarrollo de la Selva Peruana, AIDESEP.
  • Peter Hughes: Columban missionary priest and coordinator of Human and Territorial Rights in the Amazon in REPAM, a Catholic Church network promoting the lives and dignity of peoples living across Amazonia.
  • Carlos Soria: environmental lawyer, teacher and researcher at the Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú.

The Moderator was Vanessa Baird: PSG steering committee member. Co-editor and co-director of the New Internationalist.

A brief account follows, and a fuller account will be posted in Spanish and English later in the week here.

The panel’s presentation was of a situation that is tragic, yet with elements of hope. The tragedy is evident in the death rates among indigenous populations, reaching four times Peru’s national average at the worst point. The panel argued that this reflects historical neglect and a fragile state presence (especially in the area of health); in many parts of Amazonia the state is effectively absent. The panel also stressed the lack of an understanding of indigenous culture.

The panel agreed that government intervention, rather than protecting health and controlling the virus, had encouraged its spread amongst the indigenous population. Where indigenous authorities closed the frontiers of their territories, the spread of Covid proved manageable but where civil and military authorities disputed their right to do so, the virus spread more quickly. Peru’s formal governmental system refuses to recognise indigenous peoples’ definition of their frontiers.

The most telling anecdote concerned the arrival of a navy boat on one of the region’s rivers, the Napo, bringing ‘help’ and insisting that everyone stay in their houses. The local leaders explained that they were already in firm community lockdown. They were observing their borders rigorously with people able to pursue their livelihoods within those confines. The military on the boat would not accept this, and infections resulted.

The panel emphasized a theme that will be developed more fully in the next webinar when we discuss the challenges of the economic recovery. Government encouragement for an early restoration of oil and gas production in the Amazon gave Covid additional vigour, spreading the virus further amongst the indigenous population. The decision brought protests that resulted in fatal confrontations with the police guarding oil installations on indigenous lands. The pandemic has seen an increase in deaths of environmental defenders. As Lizardo Cauper put it “we asked President Vizcarra to send us medicine, but he sent us police.”

Another theme raised by the panel was that of land rights. Indigenous land rights have never been a government priority. It has taken the state more than 50 years to issue land titles to some 2,700 communities, with around 1,000 pending. Industrialised agriculture and logging concerns can secure property rights on indigenous lands within weeks.

The hope? For the panel this lay in the community response once the nature of the crisis was understood and the lack of outside help made manifest. To treat the symptoms of Covid and help boost their immune systems, indigenous peoples have relied on traditional herbal medicine and their own practitioners. In Ucayali, volunteers bottled and distributed herbal beverages. The Federation of Cucama women established a radio network of correspondents to connect communities. In Iquitos, the church raised enough money through crowd funding to provide an oxygen machine which the state had failed to do. The ‘collective quarantine’ was a healthy community response.

All the panellists stressed the importance of international solidarity in helping indigenous peoples weather the current crisis and in stemming the concomitant problem of deforestation which is destroying their habitat.

The next webinar will take place on Saturday 17 October at 4pm (UK time), 10am (Peru time). Register and put it in your diary!