“Huelga indefinida” (“Indefinite strike”), “Viva el SUTEP” (“long live SUTEP”), “Alan corrupto” (“corrupt Alan”) and other such slogans have been emblazoned across Peru for the last few weeks as state school teachers engaged in a national strike. The strike followed Congress’ approval on July 11th of a controversial bill for the Ley de Carrera Pública Magisterial (Public Teacher Career Law).

Teachers take to the streets
The main points of the law refer to the need for the evaluation of state school teachers as the basis for promotion and higher pay based on merit. The main bone of contention is Article 27, which outlines the requirement for teachers to be monitored periodically. The law introduces the testing of teachers’ professional abilities. It stipulates the need for further training for those teachers who fail two tests in a row. If they fail a third time, the law says they should be removed from their posts. They could then either sit a public exam to work as a teaching assistant or receive financial compensation depending on their length of service.

Government vs. SUTEP
The government claims that the law is fundamental to improving the quality of education and ensuring teachers in state schools are up to the job. Educational standards in Peru are low. According to Mercedes Cabanillas, the president of Congress, the law aims to optimise the quality of teachers through training and teachers will be remunerated as they move up the scale. She has also announced that Congress will undertake an information campaign so that teachers know exactly what the law says.

However, Luis Muñoz, the general secretary of the teachers’ union SUTEP (Sindicato Unitario de Trabajadores en la Educación del Perú;), believes that the law is an insult to the teaching profession. He states that the government “is just looking to privatise education”, dismissing its position as “neo-liberal”. He says that the law will lead to “massive dismissals and salary cuts”.

Broader issues
The reform of the country’s public education system, renowned for its poor infrastructure and teacher training, initially received widespread public support. This was especially so when, in February, the results of evaluations carried out at the end of last year were published. These showed that almost one-half of all state school teachers could not solve basic maths problems and that one-third had difficulties in reading comprehension.

SUTEP has long been controlled by Patria Roja, a left-wing political party with an originally Maoist agenda. The government believes that this political control has been one of the main reasons why it has been so difficult to introduce reforms into the teaching profession.

Those who oppose the law, on the other hand, believe that there is a problem with the evaluations themselves and critics fear that the new law will lead to arbitrary or politically-motivated sackings if and when teachers fail these tests.

Another criticism of the new law is that it was approved after virtually no dialogue with teachers’ organisations, parent-teacher associations or organisations working on educational issues. SUTEP is convinced that the ruling APRA party wants to use educational reform as a way of undermining the union, which has long been one of Peru’s most powerful.

The problems afflicting the education system in Peru are deep-rooted, and arguably cannot simply be attributed to the teachers. According to the Roundtable in the Fight against Poverty (a coordinating body that brings together the state and civil society), educational spending per person is only 41% of the average for Latin America as a whole. The law refers to state education only, and private education is not addressed.

What now?
Strike action was officially suspended on the July 19th and a mediation forum has been established to encourage dialogue between the government and the union. Controversy immediately surfaced when the government decided to take action to force regional governments not to pay teachers for the days on which they had been on strike. A number of regional presidents have protested about this. Divisions have also emerged within SUTEP over the decision to suspend the strike, for instance in Puno (where strike action began in mid-June) and in Arequipa. These regions have announced plans to hold further protests.

(This is an edited version of the full article which appears in the PSG’s Peru Update publication No. 122 and is sent to members on a bi-monthly basis)