At the end of 2006, the Inter American Court of Human Rights (IACHR) dictated sentences on two cases from 1992. One ruled the Peruvian State responsible for the killing of nine students and a university teacher from La Cantuta University; the second for the execution of 41 prisoners accused of terrorism in Castro Castro prison. In both, Peru was ordered to pay reparations to the victim’s families and to hold a memorial ceremony.
The second ruling in particular has caused controversy. Conservative groups have rejected it outright, declaring it favours terrorism. There are cries to withdraw from the IAHR system, with claims it does not respect State sovereignty and makes unrealistic demands that poor countries pay overpriced reparations to terrorists, which could be dangerous for State security.
There is also a constitutional accusation against Toledo for having recognised the crime committed. (Alan García did the same in the La Cantuta case).
According to police investigations, witnesses and the TRC, Fujimori and Montesinos ordered the massacre of Shining Path members in the prison.
Human rights groups and public figures such as Salomon Lerner, the former President of the TRC, have stood out to say Peru has ethical, political and judicial obligations to pay reparations to all victims of human rights abuses, regardless of their prior positions.
Peru has signed the San Jose Pact, allowing the IACHR competence in matters of human rights, therefore must respect its decisions which are binding and non reversible. To do otherwise would defend extra judicial executions and promote impunity. A precedent of rejecting court sentences that are not to everyone’s advantage could be dangerous for the rule of law.
There is much debate and name calling around the matter. What is certain is that the killings in Castro Castro cannot go unpunished. Much attention is being paid to the reparations, yet little is being said about those responsible who ordered the selective massacre of 41 prisoners, namely Fujimori, Montesinos, the infamous ex-head of the secret service and Nicolás Hermoza Ríos.
Alan Garcia has stated he will not pull out of the court and in the next few days it will be decided if Peru will demand an interpretation of the sentence which could take up to 90 days to be given.
Recent Comments