The PSG supported by the LSE’s Peruvian society, organised a discussion on ‘Fujimori’s Trial and the Role of International Human Rights Law’. The event, which was attended by 50 people, was chaired by Professor George Philip from the LSE.
First to speak was John Crabtree from the Latin American Centre at Oxford University. He provided the political context to Fujimori’s years in power during which the alleged crimes of human rights abuse and corruption occurred. However, he pointed out that most of the 70,000 people who lost their lives during two decades of Peru’s civil conflict took place under the administrations of Fernando Belaunde Terry (1980-85) and Alan Garcia (1985-1990) and that most of the deaths occurred in and around Ayacucho. Responsibility for these crimes lies equally with Shining Path and state security forces. However, the massacres at Barrios Altos (1991) and La Cantuta (1992), on which this trial hangs, were committed during Fujimori’s time in office.
John described the trial as a landmark case in so much as it raises questions on issues of impunity and whether presidents, or former presidents, should be held responsible for crimes that occur during their Presidency even if they are not directly implicated.
He also said that the process would not necessarily be swift. Even if Fujimori were to be found guilty in the first round of trials, it is certain that his lawyers would take any ruling to the Supreme Court.
Clara Sandoval, a lecturer in the department of Law at the University of Essex considered the role of international human rights law (IHRL) in securing Fujimori’s extradition back to Peru. She assessed the impact of decisions taken by the Inter-American Court of Human Rights against the Peruvian state in relation to the killing of nine students and a lecturer in the La Cantuta case. She led the audience through the labyrinth that is the inter-American (IA) system, explaining that Peru was very engaged with the international organisations that comprise the IA system and since 1978 had ratified numerous IA treaties on human rights.
In his current trial, Fujimori and his legal team deny the existence of the paramilitary death squad known as the Colina group formed by members of the army, which carried out the killings. However, Clara explained that the IA system through its own research, knew of the existence of this group and this has already been proven before an IA court.
A number of actors are being prosecuted for their alleged roles in the two main cases. The recent sentencing of Julio Salazar Monroe, a retired general and former head of the National Intelligence Service (SIN), who was jailed in April for 35 years, has set an important judicial precedent. The length of his sentence has implications for Fujimori’s trial as the Colina group was an integral part of the SIN, which reported directly to the highest level of government.
Clara remains optimistic and expressed her confidence in the Peruvian judicial system and the role of prosecutors and other legal representatives to deliver justice. Judgment will in turn depend on the degree of responsibility attributed to Fujimori in both the Barrios Altos and La Cantuta cases.
A member of the audience asked to what extent heads of state should be held accountable and brought to trial for the actions of the military. The panelists clarified that under IHRL states are allowed to use force, but the excessive use of force is to be condemned. This does not mean that all heads of state can be prosecuted for the actions of the military, rather only in terms of how they act and respond to cases or revelations of military abuses and the extent they are investigated after the fact. It is clear that in Peru widespread and aggravated military abuse occurred and Fujimori did nothing.
Clara explained that Fujimori’s trial could have major implications for Latin American countries where human rights abuses have been committed under different authoritarian regimes and shows the increasing strength of IHRL.
Recent Comments